conceptual problems III

On Dec 4, 5:53 am, (Phillip Helbig---
remove CLOTHES to reply) wrote:
In article , Knecht

writes:
Relativity is safe for now and probably will remain so for quite some
time, that is, as long as we let observations resolve scientific
issues.

As the moderator's note in another post in this thread pointed out,
relativity would still be safe even without the new issues you mention.
The two things (CMB as a "universal reference frame" and how this jibes
with relativity on the one hand and the large-scale flows etc on the
other) have nothing to do with each other.


I would welcome a clear and succinct synopsis of your reasoning for
the contention that these two phenomena are unrelated. I am wondering
if there might be some disparity in our starting assumptions.

Yours in science,
Knecht
www.amherst.edu/~rloldershaw