![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Speed is meters/second.
Constant speed means a body is moving say 10 meters in a second. If the "meters" however are "expanding" what does speed mean? If in a second 10 meters become 10.00000x meters, the speed of a body with constant velocity is slowing down. The body puts 10 meters in each second but since each of those meters has grown bigger, its effective velocity is 9.999999999x meters? In an expanding universe everything is slowing down then ? But then, how can we measure the expanding meters? If we say 1 meter expanded to 1.00000x meter, what does THAT mean? Does it mean that in TRUE, non expanding meters, the distance between point A and B that was BEFORE 10 meters has grown to 10.000000x "standard" non expanding meters? Space expansion does not happen within our measurement meters I suppose. The meter in Paris has the same size as it had when it was created. But does it? Space has expanded in those centuries since that thing was cast. Has our meter shrunk then? Note that this are conceptual problems. It doesn't matter if somebody says that the expansion is so small that we can't measure it... The choice of a unit of measure is arbitrary. I could say that my choice of unit, instead of the old fashioned meters, is the distance between my keyboard here and the center of the Virgo cluster. I would use the unit 1 V for Virgo. Yes, it would be impractical in everyday life but nice for cosmological problems :-) And nothing prevents me from choosing such a unit. Then, due to space expansion, 1V grows by some centimeters each second. How much is the speed of an object expressed in Vs? If I move with 1e-1500000000000000000000000 V /second to bring my daughter from school in my motorcycle, each second my speed is changing, my motorcycle slowing down a bit since my unit of measure is expanding! Up to now all the answers I got was that space expansion happens far away, where we can't see it, in the immense voids between galaxies. In another words: "do not worry jacob. Space is expanding but physics goes on as usual" They propose two kinds of space units: a) Small ones like the one in Paris, that do not expand at all. b) Big units like the "V" unit above, that shouldn't be used. They are unreliable because they expand... How can we know for sure when a unit starts to expand and when it stays the same? i.e. at WHICH SIZE in non expanding meters does a unit begin to "feel" space expansion??? That is kind of difficult question. Most BB people get angry at this point and cut the conversation. When I speak about common sense I mean logic, not prejudice. I am ready to accept far fetched conclusions, even that space is expanding when logic would be preserved. jacob |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
NASA PDF - Apollo Experience Reports - 114 reports | Rusty | History | 1 | July 27th 05 03:52 AM |
[ANN] xmds-1.3-4 released! xmds solves complex problems simply and quickly | Paul Cochrane | Research | 0 | June 18th 04 12:48 PM |
[ANN] xmds-1.3-4 released! xmds solves complex problems simply and quickly | Paul Cochrane | Astronomy Misc | 0 | June 18th 04 07:06 AM |
xmds solves complex problems simply and quickly | Paul Cochrane | Astronomy Misc | 0 | April 27th 04 10:09 AM |
TMI Report:People problems vs. Equipment | Jim M Bowden | Space Shuttle | 0 | October 22nd 03 08:08 AM |