On Apr 2, 10:19 am, wrote:
There is this thing that physicists have regarding charge, that is
just such an ingrained concept, from the standard model, that only by
really asking yourself what is charge, can you get past that concept.

If, in your analysis of charge, you end up with "Well it is a
fundamental property of"

Then stop and analyze what you are actually saying.

You are saying it is a decree.

No, no. All Uncle Al is saying is that any theory that claims to
replace some current one must be at least AS GOOD which simply means:
it must predict all the experimental results the old theory predicted.
Uncle A. posted a sample list of results any new theory must predict
or else it's just hand waving.

--
Jan Bielawski