SpamBot
August 6th 03, 02:06 AM
In article >, John Maxson
> wrote:
> Michael Gardner > wrote in message
> ...
> > In article >,
> > "John Maxson" > wrote:
> >
> > > I gave you Doherty as a reference for verifying that I have 51-L, RCS
> > > telemetry, and for no other reason. I could care less about either his
> > > or your RCS opinions on 51-L. You were not there, not in the loop.
> > >
> > no, you gave me him as a reference when I asked about what evidence
> > you had for the telemetry - saying you gave him a copy. So I asked him
> > what he remembered about the telemetry and I relayed it here. I'm sure
> > you have RCS telemetry. I'm just as sure it does not conclusively show
> > what you are claiming and so when given an opportunity to ask someone
> > else who had actually seen it, someone who claimed to have worked on
> > the issue for years, I asked for his reading. While he may have done the
> > interview it does't seem that his recollections exactly line up with
> > yoru claims. We are back where we started. You either have clear
> > telemetry showing RCS activity or you have nothing that you can bring
> > forth except your suspicions. The answer is clear.
>
> Here's what's clear, Gardner. You are a heckler; you have treated me
> unprofessionally and like the scum of the earth. I referred you to
> someone who could verify that I have 51-L RCS telemetry. You and
> Herbert have put your spin on that (with no supporting links, of course).
> The Google archives (which you by-pass) record what I've written.
>
> Find someone else with 51-L telemetry showing RCS firings, if you're
> so positive that it does not show what Sam Beddingfield claimed as an
> expert witness on PBS. Ask yourself how many times you have tritely
> told me (like Berndt and Balettie) that you were through replying to me.
> --
> John Thomas Maxson, Retired Engineer (Aerospace)
> Author, The Betrayal of Mission 51-L (www.mission51l.com)
"Find someone else with the same evidence I have and look at it..."
Translation: I have no evidence to show.
Put up or shut up.
> wrote:
> Michael Gardner > wrote in message
> ...
> > In article >,
> > "John Maxson" > wrote:
> >
> > > I gave you Doherty as a reference for verifying that I have 51-L, RCS
> > > telemetry, and for no other reason. I could care less about either his
> > > or your RCS opinions on 51-L. You were not there, not in the loop.
> > >
> > no, you gave me him as a reference when I asked about what evidence
> > you had for the telemetry - saying you gave him a copy. So I asked him
> > what he remembered about the telemetry and I relayed it here. I'm sure
> > you have RCS telemetry. I'm just as sure it does not conclusively show
> > what you are claiming and so when given an opportunity to ask someone
> > else who had actually seen it, someone who claimed to have worked on
> > the issue for years, I asked for his reading. While he may have done the
> > interview it does't seem that his recollections exactly line up with
> > yoru claims. We are back where we started. You either have clear
> > telemetry showing RCS activity or you have nothing that you can bring
> > forth except your suspicions. The answer is clear.
>
> Here's what's clear, Gardner. You are a heckler; you have treated me
> unprofessionally and like the scum of the earth. I referred you to
> someone who could verify that I have 51-L RCS telemetry. You and
> Herbert have put your spin on that (with no supporting links, of course).
> The Google archives (which you by-pass) record what I've written.
>
> Find someone else with 51-L telemetry showing RCS firings, if you're
> so positive that it does not show what Sam Beddingfield claimed as an
> expert witness on PBS. Ask yourself how many times you have tritely
> told me (like Berndt and Balettie) that you were through replying to me.
> --
> John Thomas Maxson, Retired Engineer (Aerospace)
> Author, The Betrayal of Mission 51-L (www.mission51l.com)
"Find someone else with the same evidence I have and look at it..."
Translation: I have no evidence to show.
Put up or shut up.