|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Rodney Kelp wrote:
How do you get a nitrogen atmosphere from a moon that has methane oceans? It is so cold that the methane does not have a very high vapor pressure, so the atmosphere can keep only a little mixed in as vapor before it rains out. Nitrogen is left. If it was a bit colder, that would rain out, too. -- John Popelish |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Robert Hartwick wrote: On a related matter, I was expecting to see a few photos at low altitudes (less than a thousand meters). There was supposed to be a spotlight to facilitate this. Has anyone seen anything of these? Were they lost? We seem to go from kilometers high directly to the 'pebbles on the mud'. Disappointing. The descent animation at http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/cassini/multimedia/pia07234.html shows images at 2.3 km, 2.1, 1.8, 1.7, 1.5, 1.3, 1.2, 1.0, 800 m, 700 and 500. They planned to suspend imaging a few hundred meters above the surface, so that they would have time to transfer the final in-air shots and other data before a possibly fatal impact. The lamp was supposed to come on at 400 m, but it's purpose was mainly for spectroscopy. The Descent Imager Spectral Radiometer Aboard Huygens is a good read: http://www.rssd.esa.int/SB/HUYGENS/docs/SP1177/tomask_1.pdf -- Hud Nordin Silicon Valley |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
"Rodney Kelp" wrote in message
... How do you get a nitrogen atmosphere from a moon that has methane oceans? Ask the same question of Earth, how do we have a nitrogen atmosphere with liquid water oceans? Briefly, there's every reason to expect materials with similar boiling points (and more importantly, molecular masses) to be present on a given body. Loss mechanisms for the atmosphere can be absorptive (like the CO2 that was soaked up to form carbonates on Earth) or 'exhaustive' where the material is lost from the planet by exoatmospheric escape. So, if Titan accreted a shedload of methane in its early life (maybe...) then there's nothing to have stopped a comparable cosmic-abundance-worth of nitrogen being trapped too. Do a trawl for 'Lunine' and 'J.S.Lewis' for papers (NASA ADS for starters) and ideas. -James Garry (ex Huygens payload tweaker) |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Well, we know plants give off nitrogen at night.
What plants are on Titan? "Paul F. Dietz" wrote in message ... Rodney Kelp wrote: How do you get a nitrogen atmosphere from a moon that has methane oceans? How do you get a (mostly) nitrogen atmosphere from a planet that has water oceans? Paul |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
That might cause pools of liquid nitrogen mighten it?
"John Popelish" wrote in message ... Rodney Kelp wrote: How do you get a nitrogen atmosphere from a moon that has methane oceans? It is so cold that the methane does not have a very high vapor pressure, so the atmosphere can keep only a little mixed in as vapor before it rains out. Nitrogen is left. If it was a bit colder, that would rain out, too. -- John Popelish |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Nitrogen is common to all terrestrial atmospheres we currently know of.
Mars has it, though only 3%. The rest is primarily co2. Venus has it, same figure. If you take away the co2 (the vast majority, and a primary cause of the intense pressure), you're left with a nitrogen atmosphere only twice as thick as Earth's, so in most ways that count Venus has quite a bit of nitrogen with no plant life possible on it. Earth has a predominantly nitrogen atmosphere, with oxygen making up only a 5th of it and everything else negligible. Much of this is because the far heavier methane atmosphere we used to have, along with the not inconsiderable co2 content, have been chemically leeched out by geologic and biological methods. Had there been no life, we'd have either an almost entirely nitrogen atmosphere w/ higher co2 levels, or methane would not break down well and would be a considerable atmospheric component. Nitrogen appears to be a default when everything else is taken away (in Earth's case, it's the only gas that isn't being stripped out on a large scale... in Titan's case, it's the only gas that doesn't precipitate there that we know of). "Rodney Kelp" wrote in message ... Well, we know plants give off nitrogen at night. What plants are on Titan? "Paul F. Dietz" wrote in message ... Rodney Kelp wrote: How do you get a nitrogen atmosphere from a moon that has methane oceans? How do you get a (mostly) nitrogen atmosphere from a planet that has water oceans? Paul |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Rodney Kelp wrote:
Well, we know plants give off nitrogen at night. What other falsehoods do you 'know'? Paul |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Rodney Kelp wrote:
That might cause pools of liquid nitrogen mighten it? That depends on whether the surface pressure is high enough to raise the boiling temperature of nitrogen higher than the surface temperature... or whether the surface temperature is lower than the boiling temperature of nitrogen at the surface atmospheric pressure. -- John Popelish |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Everett Hickey wrote: Earth has a predominantly nitrogen atmosphere, with oxygen making up only a 5th of it and everything else negligible. Much of this is because the far heavier methane atmosphere we used to have, along with the not inconsiderable co2 content, have been chemically leeched out... Current belief is that Earth's atmosphere never had significant methane (or ammonia). It was always an oxidizing atmosphere, dominated by CO2. Earth's early atmosphere almost certainly looked a whole lot like Venus's current atmosphere, except cooler and having more water vapor. In fact, that's what Venus's atmosphere looked like then too. (The key difference is just distance from the Sun: Earth's surface, even with a thick CO2 atmosphere, never got warm enough to boil the oceans. On Venus, once the oceans started to boil, there was no going back, because water vapor is a powerful greenhouse gas: the oceans boiled dry, surface temperature soared, solar UV broke down the water into hydrogen and oxygen, and the hydrogen was lost. Earth never got that hot, and the oceans slowly converted the CO2 into carbonate rock.) ...Had there been no life, we'd have either an almost entirely nitrogen atmosphere w/ higher co2 levels... There probably wouldn't be a lot of CO2 left. The CO2 was taken out by chemical processes in the ocean; life was not involved in that until the very end. -- "Think outside the box -- the box isn't our friend." | Henry Spencer -- George Herbert | |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
John Popelish wrote:
Rodney Kelp wrote: That might cause pools of liquid nitrogen mighten it? That depends on whether the surface pressure is high enough to raise the boiling temperature of nitrogen higher than the surface temperature... or whether the surface temperature is lower than the boiling temperature of nitrogen at the surface atmospheric pressure. Temperatures in the polar regions would perhaps be low enough to liquefy nitrogen. Titan's orbital period around Saturn is 16 Earth days, and its rotational period is also 16 days, so even in equatorial regions things must get even colder during the 8 days of night, perhaps low enough to liquefy nitrogen. -- Scott M. Kozel Highway and Transportation History Websites Virginia/Maryland/Washington, D.C. http://www.roadstothefuture.com Philadelphia and Delaware Valley http://www.pennways.com |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The Apollo Hoax FAQ (is not spam) :-) | Nathan Jones | Misc | 6 | July 29th 04 06:14 AM |
Cassini Image: The Veils of Titan | Ron | Astronomy Misc | 0 | May 6th 04 06:05 PM |
The Apollo FAQ (moon landings were faked) | Nathan Jones | UK Astronomy | 8 | February 4th 04 07:48 PM |