A Space & astronomy forum. SpaceBanter.com

Go Back   Home » SpaceBanter.com forum » Astronomy and Astrophysics » Astronomy Misc
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Linear extrapolated fossil data tries to tell that perhaps Earth andMoon formed as a planet couple ?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old April 27th 17, 07:53 AM posted to sci.astro
Hannu Poropudas[_2_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 26
Default Linear extrapolated fossil data tries to tell that perhaps Earth andMoon formed as a planet couple ?

How to calculate with my extrapolated fossil data of Pannella G.:

T’ = length of the month recorded by marine life (= synodic month)
t’ = length of the day recorded by marine life (= solar day)
T = length of sidereal month
t = length of sidereal day
T = T’ /(1+T’/Y)
t = t’ /(1+t’/Y), this is very nearly equal to t’
S = T’ / t’ = number of days in month recorded in paleontological specimens.
Y = length of the year (= tropical year, this is assumed to be constant = 365,2422 days = not changed significantly)
Reference:
Runcorn, S. K., 1970.
Paleontological Measurements of the Changes in the Rotation Rates of Earth and Moon and
of the Rate of Retreat of the Moon from the Earth., pages 17-23, page 21.
In:
Runcorn S.K. (Editor), 1970.
Paleogeophysics.
Academic Press Inc., Printed in Great Britain, 518 pages, pages 17-23.

For example

(figures from my drawings one example out of range of experimental
test points for curiosity):

-4600*10^4 centuries (approx.. Earth’s formation time, 4600 Ma ago)

11 hours/day (present hours, assumption Earth and Sun distance have not significantly changed, Y = 365,2422 days, solar days and tropical year)

Y = 780 * 11 h = 8580 h (present hours) = 357,5 days (present solar days, Y changed little (?) in data of tables it is used Y=365,2422 days)

780 days/year (solar days and tropical year)

48 days/month (solar days and synodic month) = T’

T = T’ /(1+T’/Y) = 48 / (1 + 48/357,5) = 42,31812577 =
= approx. 42 days/sidereal month

Distance approximately between Earth and Moon at approx. 4600 Ma ago.

G = 6,67*10^(-11)*N*m^^2/kg^2
M = 5,974*10^24 kg

P = 42,31812577*11*60*60 s (present seconds) = 1675797,781 s

r = ( G*M*P^2/(4*Pi^2) )^()1/3 = 304832464,1 m =
= approx. 305000 km.

So linear extrapolated fossil data tries to tell that perhaps
Earth and Moon formed as a planet couple ?

Best Regards,

Hannu Poropudas

_________________COPIES OF MY OLD ARTICLES BELOW (long)_________________

Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella’s Fossil Time Data for Test Purposes
1 kirjoittajan 2 viestiä



mathematician

13.12.2008
Käännä viesti kielelle: suomi

Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella’s Fossil Time Data for Test
Purposes
(Author: Hannu K.J. Poropudas, Vesaisentie 9E, 90900 Kiiminki,
Finland, Date: 12.12.2008)
Three rough data set (TABLE 1, days/month, TABLE 2, days/year and
TABLE 3, months/year)
are given in this paper for test purposes of ancient fossil time data.
Numbers are based
on Giorgio Pannella’s (1972) fossil time data. Interpretations are my
own.
These linear extrapolations are based also on uncertain assumption of
existence of
oscillation about 429.4 Ma in Pannella’s Figure 3 (days/month). Many
ages and fossil
points are still uncertain. Main intended area of use of these figures
is about 0-2000 Ma.

Tables of fossil time data
TABLE 1
-T/10^4 Days/Month
centuries
----------------------------
0 29,16
18,6 29,4
31,4 29,69
45,4 29,83
58,1 30,05
74,4 29,95
206,9 29,67
291,9 30,09
342,2 30,36
380,3 30,57
416,7 30,55
429,4 30,98
448 31,22
460,8 31,51
467,6 31,24
474,8 31,65
487,5 31,87
503,8 31,77
639 31,49
721,3 31,91
771,6 32,18
809,7 32,39
846,1 32,37
858,8 32,81
877,4 33,05
890,2 33,34
897 33,06
904,2 33,48
916,9 33,7
933,2 33,6
1068,4 33,32
1150,7 33,74
1201 34,01
1239,1 34,22
1275,5 34,2
1288,2 34,63
1306,8 34,87
1319,6 35,16
1326,4 34,89
1333,6 35,3
1346,3 35,52
1362,6 35,42
1497,8 35,14
1580,1 35,56
1630,4 35,83
1668,5 36,04
1704,9 36,02
1717,6 36,46
1736,2 36,7
1749 36,99
1755,8 36,71
1763 37,13
1775,7 37,35
1792 37,25
1927,2 36,97
2009,5 37,39
-----------------------
2059,8 37,66
2097,9 37,87
2134,3 37,85
2147 38,28
2165,6 38,52
2178,4 38,81
2185,2 38,54
2192,4 38,95
2205,1 39,17
2221,4 39,07
2356,6 38,79
2438,9 39,21
2489,2 39,48
2527,3 39,69
2563,7 39,67
2576,4 40,11
2595 40,35
2607,8 40,64
2614,6 40,36
2621,8 40,78
2634,5 41
2650,8 40,9
2786 40,62
2868,3 41,04
2918,6 41,31
2956,7 41,52
2993,1 41,5
3005,8 41,93
3024,4 42,17
3037,2 42,46
3044 42,19
3051,2 42,6
3063,9 42,82
3080,2 42,72
3215,4 42,44
3297,7 42,86
3348 43,13
3386,1 43,34
3422,5 43,32
3435,2 43,76
3453,8 44
3466,6 44,29
3473,4 44,01
3480,6 44,43
3493,3 44,65
3509,6 44,55
3644,8 44,27
3727,1 44,69
3777,4 44,96
3815,5 45,17
-----------------------
3851,9 45,15
3864,6 45,58
3883,2 45,82
3896 46,11
3902,8 45,84
3910 46,25
3922,7 46,47
3939 46,37
4074,2 46,09
4156,5 46,51
4206,8 46,78
4244,9 46,99
4281,3 46,97
4294 47,41
4312,6 47,65
4325,4 47,94
4332,2 47,66
4339,4 48,08
4352,1 48,3
4368,4 48,2
4503,6 47,92
-----------------------
(4585,9 48,34
4636,2 48,61
4674,3 48,82
4710,7 48,8
4761,6 49,49)
TABLE 2
-T/10^4 Days/Year
centuries
---------------------------
0 364,76
52,2 370,95
52,2 374,76
226,2 370,95
276,9 381,46
276,9 391,22
335,6 393,66
340,2 397,56
340,2 400,16
367,8 400,65
367,8 404,52
367,8 412,26
394,5 400,65
408,2 418,06
429,4 404,09
435,8 413,23
445 424
481,6 410,28
481,6 414,09
558,1 431,76
655,6 410,28
706,3 420,79
706,3 430,55
765 432,99
769,6 436,89
769,6 439,49
797,2 439,98
797,2 443,85
797,2 451,59
823,9 439,98
837,6 457,39
858,8 443,42
865,2 452,56
874,4 463,33
911 449,61
911 453,42
987,5 471,09
1085 449,61
1135,7 460,12
1135,7 469,88
1194,4 472,32
1199 476,22
1199 478,82
1226,6 479,31
1226,6 483,18
1226,6 490,92
1253,3 479,31
1267 496,72
1288,2 482,75
1294,6 491,89
1303,8 502,66
1340,4 488,94
1340,4 492,75
1416,9 510,42
1514,4 488,94
1565,1 499,45
1565,1 509,21
1623,8 511,65
1628,4 515,55
1628,4 518,15
1656 518,64
1656 522,51
1656 530,25
1682,7 518,64
1696,4 536,05
1717,6 522,08
1724 531,22
1733,2 541,99
1769,8 528,27
1769,8 532,08
1846,3 549,75
1943,8 528,27
1994,5 538,78
1994,5 548,54
-------------------------
2053,2 550,98
2057,8 554,88
2057,8 557,48
2085,4 557,97
2085,4 561,84
2085,4 569,58
2112,1 557,97
2125,8 575,38
2147 561,41
2153,4 570,55
2162,6 581,32
2199,2 567,6
2199,2 571,41
2275,7 589,08
2373,2 567,6
2423,9 578,11
2423,9 587,87
2482,6 590,31
2487,2 594,21
2487,2 596,81
2514,8 597,3
2514,8 601,17
2514,8 608,91
2541,5 597,3
2555,2 614,71
2576,4 600,75
2582,8 609,88
2592 620,65
2628,6 606,94
2628,6 610,75
2705,1 628,41
2802,6 606,94
2853,3 617,45
2853,3 627,21
2912 629,65
2916,6 633,55
2916,6 636,15
2944,2 636,64
2944,2 640,51
2944,2 648,25
2970,9 636,64
2984,6 654,05
3005,8 640,08
3012,2 649,22
3021,4 659,99
3058 646,27
3058 650,08
3134,5 667,75
3232 646,27
3282,7 656,78
3282,7 666,54
3341,4 668,98
3346 672,88
3346 675,48
3373,6 675,97
3373,6 679,84
3373,6 687,58
3400,3 675,97
3414 693,38
3435,2 679,41
3441,6 688,55
3450,8 699,32
3487,4 685,6
3487,4 689,41
3563,9 707,08
3661,4 685,6
3712,1 696,11
3712,1 705,87
3770,8 708,31
3775,4 712,21
3775,4 714,81
3803 715,3
3803 719,17
3803 726,91
-------------------------
3829,7 715,3
3843,4 732,71
3864,6 718,74
3871 727,88
3880,2 738,65
3916,8 724,93
3916,8 728,74
3993,3 746,41
4090,8 724,93
4141,5 735,44
4141,5 745,2
4200,2 747,64
4204,8 751,54
4204,8 754,14
4232,4 754,63
4232,4 758,5
4232,4 766,24
4259,1 754,63
4272,8 772,04
4294 758,07
4300,4 767,21
4309,6 777,98
4346,2 764,26
4346,2 768,07
4422,7 785,74
4520,2 764,26
-------------------------
(4570,9 774,77
4570,9 784,53
4629,6 786,97
4634,2 790,87
4634,2 793,47
4661,8 793,96
4661,8 797,83
4661,8 805,57
4688,5 793,96
4702,2 811,37
4723,4 797,4
4729,8 806,54
4739 817,31
4775,6 803,59
4775,6 807,4
4852,1 825,07)

TABLE 3
-T/10^4 Months/Year
centuries
------------------------------
0 12,34
70 12,49
70 12,6
160,7 11,56
220 12,55
290 12,71
340 13,11
360 12,93
360 13,35
429,4 12,95
499,4 13,1
499,4 13,21
510 13
590,1 12,17
649,4 13,16
719,4 13,32
769,4 13,72
789,4 13,54
789,4 13,96
858,8 13,56
928,8 13,71
928,8 13,82
939,4 13,61
1019,5 12,78
1078,8 13,77
1148,8 13,93
1198,8 14,33
1218,8 14,15
1218,8 14,57
1288,2 14,17
1358,2 14,32
1358,2 14,43
1368,8 14,22
1448,9 13,39
1508,2 14,38
1578,2 14,54
1628,2 14,94
1648,2 14,76
1648,2 15,18
1717,6 14,78
1787,6 14,93
1787,6 15,04
1798,2 14,83
1878,3 14
1937,6 14,99
2007,6 15,15
------------------------
2057,6 15,55
2077,6 15,37
2077,6 15,79
2147 15,39
2217 15,54
2217 15,65
2227,6 15,44
2307,7 14,61
2367 15,6
2437 15,76
2487 16,16
2507 15,98
2507 16,4
2576,4 16
2646,4 16,15
2646,4 16,26
2657 16,05
2737,1 15,22
2796,4 16,21
2866,4 16,37
2916,4 16,77
2936,4 16,59
2936,4 17,01
3005,8 16,61
3075,8 16,76
3075,8 16,87
3086,4 16,66
3166,5 15,83
3225,8 16,82
3295,8 16,98
3345,8 17,38
3365,8 17,2
3365,8 17,62
3435,2 17,22
3505,2 17,37
3505,2 17,48
3515,8 17,27
3595,9 16,44
3655,2 17,43
3725,2 17,59
3775,2 17,99
3795,2 17,81
3795,2 18,23
------------------------
3864,6 17,83
3934,6 17,98
3934,6 18,09
3945,2 17,88
4025,3 17,05
4084,6 18,04
4154,6 18,2
4204,6 18,6
4224,6 18,42
4224,6 18,84
4294 18,44
4364 18,59
4364 18,7
4374,6 18,49
4454,7 17,66
4514 18,65
-----------------------
(4584 18,81
4634 19,21
4654 19,03
4654 19,45
4723,4 19,05
4793,4 19,2
4793,4 19,31
4804 19,1
4884,1 18,27
4943,4 19,26)
References:
Pannella Giorgio, 1972.
Paleontological Evidence on the Earth’s Rotational History Since Early
Precambrian.
Astrophysics and Space Science, 16, (1972), 212-237.
(Figure 3 on page 235 and Figure 4 on page 236. Mean solar day,
Synodic Month, Tropical Year.
Exact age of sedimentation of the Gunflint Formation is 1878.3+-1.3
Ma, YPM-IP-28510/28511.)
Scrutton, C.T., (1964), 1965.
Periodicity in Devonian Coral Growth.
Paleontology, volume 7, part 4, pages 552-558, plates 86-87.
(Middle Devonian OUM DT2 fossil, age is 385.3 Ma – 397.5 Ma, GT2004,
approximate linear formula 12.37 – 1.43*10^(-7)*T, months/year,
T=centuries,
past time minus signed).
Scrutton, C.T., 1970.
Evidence for a monthly periodicity in the growth of some corals.
In:
Runcorn, S.K. (editor), 1970.
Paleogeophysics. Academic Press, London, pages 11-16.
Fralick, P., Davis, D.W., Kissin, S.A., 2002.
The age of the Gunflint Formation, Ontario, Canada: single zircon U-Pb
age determinations
from reworked volcanic ash.
Can. J. Earth Sci., 39, 1085-1091.
From: mathematician
Newsgroups: sci.bio.paleontology,sci.astro,sci.geo.geology,sci .physics,sci.math
Subject: Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella’s Fossil Time Data for Test Purposes
Date: Sat, 13 Dec 2008 01:46:49 -0800 (PST)
Message-ID:
NNTP-Posting-Date: Sat, 13 Dec 2008 09:46:50 +0000 (UTC)

Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated Pannella's fossil time data
1 kirjoittajan 2 viestiä



mathematician

14.1.2009
Muut vastaanottajat:
Käännä viesti kielelle: suomi

Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated Pannella's
fossil time data
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Author: H.K.J. Poropudas, Vesaisentie 9E, 90900 Kiiminki, Finland.
Date: 13.1.2009)
Below are few rough estimations of ancient time data. It should be
remembered that
these linear extrapolations are based on my uncertain assumption of
existence of
oscillation of period 429.4 Ma in Pannella's figure 3 (reference 2)
and ages
and data of fossils and stromatolites are in many cases uncertain
too.

The Elatina Formation and Reynella Siltstone
-----------------------------------------------------------------
620 Ma:
-----------
655.6 Ma, 410.28 days/year
(Drawn extrapolated figures give roughly approx. 412 days/year)
639 Ma, 31.49 days/year
(Drawn extrapolated figures give roughly approx. 31.7 days/month)
410.28/31.49 = 13.03 months/year, (primary value = 13.1 +-0.1 months/
year)
649.4 Ma, 13.16 months/year (OUM-DT2 based)
(primary value = 13.1 +-0.1 months/year)
(Drawn extrapolated figures give 412/31.7 = 13.0 months/year)
(13.0-13.2 months/year)

The Big Cottonwood Formation
--------------------------------------------
900 Ma:
-----------
890.2 Ma, 33.34 days/month
897 Ma, 33.06 days/month
904.2 Ma, 33.48 days/month
(33-33.5 days/month, average = 33.29 days/month)
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 33.4 days/month)
874.4 Ma, 463.33 days/year
911 Ma, 449.61 days/year
911 Ma, 453.42 days/year
(450-463 days/year, average = 455.45 days/year)
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 451 days/year)
455.45/33.29 = 13.68 months/year, (primary value 13.5 months/year)
(Drawn extrapolated figures give 451/33.4 = 13.5 months/year)
928.8 Ma, 13.71 months/year (OUM-DT2 based)
928.8 Ma, 13.82 months/year (OUM-DT2 based)
(13.7-13.8 months/year, primary value 13.5 months/year)
(13.5-13.8 months/year)

The Weeli Wolli Formation
--------------------------------------
2450 Ma:
-------------
2438.9 Ma, 39.21 days/month
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 39.2 days/month)
2423.9 Ma, 587.87 days/year
2423.9 Ma, 578.11 days/year
(578-588 days/year, average = 582.99 days/year)
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 585 days/year)
582.99/39.21 = 14.87 months/year, (primary value = 14.5 +-0.5 months/
year)
(Drawn extrapolated figures give 585/39.2 = 14.9 months/year)
2437 Ma, 15.76 months/year (OUM-DT2 based)
(primary value = 14.5 +-0.5 months/year)
(14.9-15.8 months/year)

Reference (1).

The Gunflint Formation
------------------
1878.3 +-1.3 Ma:
------------------------
1927.2 Ma, 36.97 days/month
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 37.2 days/month)
1846.3 Ma, 549.75 days/year
(Drawn extrapolated figure gives roughly approx. 533 days/year)
549.75/36.97 = 14.87 months/year (primary value = 14 months/year)
(Drawn extrapolated figures give 533/37.2 = 14.3 months/year)
1937.6 Ma, 14.99 monnths/year (OUM-DT2 based)
(14.3-15.0 months/year)
Age of the Bulawayan stromatolite UCLA-Bul-7 ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Mode = 10-20-40, Highest Count = 41.
2576.6.4 Ma, 40.11 days/month
2595 Ma, 40.35 days/month
2607.8 Ma, 40.64 days/month
2614.6 Ma, 40.34 days/month
2621.8 Ma, 40.78 days/month
2634.5 Ma, 41 days/month
2650.8 Ma, 40.9 days/month
2786 Ma, 40.62 days/month
2868.3 Ma, 41.04 days/month
So age of the Bulawayan Stromatolite UCLA-Bul-7 could be:
2580 Ma - 2870 Ma.
(primary value of the age =
(2672 +- 12 Ma - 2715 +- 15 Ma), Upper Bulawayan Group or
(2831 +- 6 Ma - 2904 +- 9 Ma), Lower Bulawayan Group. These both
are not local age determinations from the Bubi Greenstone Belt near
Huntsman Quarries, Zimbabwe.)
Other Time Data for UCLA-Bul-7 stromatolite:
-----------------------------------------------------------------
(40-41 days/month, primary value)
(average = 40.5 days/month, primary value)
2576.4 Ma, 600.75 days/year
2582.8 Ma, 609.88 days/year
2592 Ma, 620.65 days/year
2628.6 Ma, 606.94 days/year
2628.6 Ma, 610.75 days/year
2705.1 Ma, 628.41 days/year
2802.6 Ma, 606.94 days/year
2853.3 Ma, 617.45 days/year
2853.3 Ma, 627.21 days/year
2912 Ma, 629.65 days/year
2916.6 Ma, 633.55 days/year
2916.6 Ma, 636.15 days/year
(average = 7428.33/12 = 619.03 = approx. 619 days/year)
(601-636 days/year)
619/40.5 = 15.3 months/year
OUM-DT2 based estimation:
2576.4 Ma, 16 months/year
2646.4 Ma, 16.15 months/year
2646.4 Ma, 16.26 months/year
2657 Ma, 16.05 months/year
2737.1 Ma, 15.22 months/year
2796.4 Ma, 16.21 months/year
2866.4 Ma, 16.37 months/year
2916.4 Ma, 16.77 months/year
(average = 129.03/8 = 16.13 = approx. 16.1 months/year)
(15.2 - 16.8 months/year)

References (2 and 3).

The Moodies Group
----------------------------
3225 Ma:
-------------
3215.4 Ma, 42.44 days/month
(Drawn extrapolated figure roughly gives approx. 42.8 days/month)
3232 Ma, 646.27 days/year
(Drawn extrapolated figure roughly gives approx. 650 days/year)
646.27/42.44 = 15.23 months/year
(Drawn extrapolated figures give 650/42.8 = 15.2 months/year)
3225.8 Ma, 16.82 months/year (OUM-DT2 based)
(15.2-16.8 months/year)

Reference (4).

REFERENCES:
1. Williams, G.E. 2000.
Reviews of Geophysics, 38, 1/February 2000, pages 37-59.
2. Pannella, G., 1972.
Astrophysics and Space Science, 16, (1972), 212-237.
3. Fralick,P., Davis,D.W., Kissin,S.A., 2002.
Can. J. Earth Sci., 39, 1085-1091.
4. Eriksson,K.A., Simpson,E.L., Mueller,W., 2006.
Sedimentary Geology 190 (2006), 13-24.
5. Poropudas Hannu, 2009.
Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella's Fossil Time Data for Test
Purposes.

sci.bio.paleontology, sci.astro, sci.geo.geology, sci.physics,
sci.math.
Sat, 13 Dec 2008, 10 pages.
(I have drawn four extrapolated figures (0-1200 Ma, days/year, 0-4600
Ma, days/year,
0-1200 Ma days/month, 0-4600 Ma, days/month) but unfortunately they
are not possible
to give here due this text is in ASCII-format. I could send them via
email by request.
My email address:
hanporop
(at)
luukku.com )
From: mathematician
Newsgroups: sci.bio.paleontology,sci.astro,sci.geo.geology,sci .physics,sci.math
Subject: Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated Pannella's
fossil time data
Date: Tue, 13 Jan 2009 21:52:20 -0800 (PST)
Message-ID:
NNTP-Posting-Date: Wed, 14 Jan 2009 05:52:20 +0000 (UTC)
Cc:












Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated

Pannella's fossil time data

Hannu Poropudas

21.1.2009
Käännä viesti kielelle: suomi

Earth's Rotational History from Linear
Extarpolation of Pannella's Ancient Time
Data of Fossils
----------------------------------------
(Author: Hannu K.J. Poropudas, Vesaisentie 9E,
90900 Kiiminki, Finland, Date: 13.1.2009)
Assumption: Distance between the Earth
and the Sun has not changed significantly
during Earth's life time (about 4550 Ma).
Main intended area of use of these figures
which are calculated from TABLE 2 is roughly
about 0-2000 Ma.
TABLE 4
-T/10^4 Hours/Day
centuries
-----------------
0 24,03
52,2 23,63
52,2 23,39
226,2 23,63
276,9 22,98
276,9 22,41
335,6 22,27
340,2 22,05
340,2 21,91
367,8 21,88
367,8 21,67
367,8 21,26
394,5 21,88
408,2 20,97
429,4 21,69
435,8 21,21
445 20,67
481,6 21,37
481,6 21,17
558,1 20,3
655,6 21,37
706,3 20,83
706,3 20,36
765 20,24
769,6 20,06
769,6 19,95
797,2 19,92
797,2 19,75
797,2 19,41
823,9 19,92
837,6 19,16
858,8 19,77
865,2 19,37
874,4 18,92
911 19,5
911 19,33
987,5 18,61
1085 19,5
1135,7 19,05
1135,7 18,66
1194,4 18,56
1199 18,41
1199 18,31
1226,6 18,29
1226,6 18,14
1226,6 17,86
1253,3 18,29
1267 17,65
1288,2 18,16
1294,6 17,82
1303,8 17,44
1340,4 17,93
1340,4 17,79
1416,9 17,17
1514,4 17,93
1565,1 17,55
1565,1 17,21
1623,8 17,13
1628,4 17
1628,4 16,92
1656 16,9
1656 16,78
1656 16,53
1682,7 16,9
1696,4 16,35
1717,6 16,79
1724 16,5
1733,2 16,17
1769,8 16,59
1769,8 16,47
1846,3 15,95
1943,8 16,59
1994,5 16,27
1994,5 15,98
-------------
2053,2 15,91
2057,8 15,8
2057,8 15,72
2085,4 15,71
2085,4 15,6
2085,4 15,39
2112,1 15,71
2125,8 15,23
2147 15,61
2153,4 15,36
2162,6 15,08
2199,2 15,44
2199,2 15,34
2275,7 14,88
2373,2 15,44
2423,9 15,16
2423,9 14,91
2482,6 14,85
2487,2 14,75
2487,2 14,69
2514,8 14,68
2514,8 14,58
2514,8 14,4
2541,5 14,68
2555,2 14,26
2576,4 14,59
2582,8 14,37
2592 14,12
2628,6 14,44
2628,6 14,35
2705,1 13,95
2802,6 14,44
2853,3 14,2
2853,3 13,98
2912 13,92
2916,6 13,84
2916,6 13,78
2944,2 13,77
2944,2 13,69
2944,2 13,52
2970,9 13,77
2984,6 13,4
3005,8 13,69
3012,2 13,5
3021,4 13,28
3058 13,56
3058 13,48
3134,5 13,13
3232 13,56
3282,7 13,35
3282,7 13,15
3341,4 13,1
3346 13,03
3346 12,98
3373,6 12,97
3373,6 12,89
3373,6 12,75
3400,3 12,97
3414 12,64
3435,2 12,9
3441,6 12,73
3450,8 12,53
3487,4 12,79
3487,4 12,71
3563,9 12,4
3661,4 12,79
3712,1 12,59
3712,1 12,42
3770,8 12,38
3775,4 12,31
3775,4 12,26
3803 12,25
3803 12,19
3803 12,06
-------------
3829,7 12,25
3843,4 11,96
3864,6 12,2
3871 12,04
3880,2 11,87
3916,8 12,09
3916,8 12,03
3993,3 11,74
4090,8 12,09
4141,5 11,92
4141,5 11,76
4200,2 11,72
4204,8 11,66
4204,8 11,62
4232,4 11,62
4232,4 11,56
4232,4 11,44
4259,1 11,62
4272,8 11,35
4294 11,56
4300,4 11,43
4309,6 11,27
4346,2 11,47
4346,2 11,41
4422,7 11,16
4520,2 11,47
-------------
(4570,9 11,31
4570,9 11,17
4629,6 11,14
4634,2 11,08
4634,2 11,05
4661,8 11,04
4661,8 10,99
4661,8 10,88
4688,5 11,04
4702,2 10,8
4723,4 10,99
4729,8 10,87
4739 10,73
4775,6 10,91
4775,6 10,86
4852,1 10,62
4949,6 10,91)

Reference:
Poropudas, Hannu, 2009.

Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella’s
Fossil Time Data for Test Purposes.
533c8763-511e-4ec6-a69e-8f3f1e5d1591
(at)
z6g2000pre.googlegroups.com
Sat, 13 Dec 2008 01:46:49 -0800 (PST).
10 pages.
(sci.bio.paleontology,sci.astro,sci.geo.geology,
sci.physics,sci.math)
(mathematician haporopu
(at)
luukku.com)

On Jan 14, 7:52 am, mathematician wrote:
Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated Pannella's
fossil time data
---------------------------------------------------------------------------¬---------------------------------------------

- näytä lainattu teksti -


sci.bio.paleontology, sci.astro, sci.geo.geology, sci.physics,
sci.math.
Sat, 13 Dec 2008, 10 pages.

(I have drawn four extrapolated figures (0-1200 Ma, days/year, 0-4600
Ma, days/year,
0-1200 Ma days/month, 0-4600 Ma, days/month) but unfortunately they
are not possible
to give here due this text is in ASCII-format. I could send them via
email by request.
My email address:
hanporop
(at)
luukku.com )



From: mathematician
Newsgroups: sci.bio.paleontology,sci.astro,sci.geo.geology,sci .physics,sci.math
Subject: Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated
Pannella's fossil time data
Date: Tue, 20 Jan 2009 22:19:37 -0800 (PST)
Message-ID:
References:
NNTP-Posting-Date: Wed, 21 Jan 2009 06:19:37 +0000 (UTC)


  #2  
Old April 27th 17, 03:26 PM posted to sci.astro
dlzc
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,426
Default Linear extrapolated fossil data tries to tell that perhaps Earthand Moon formed as a planet couple ?

Dear Hannu Poropudas:

On Wednesday, April 26, 2017 at 11:53:47 PM UTC-7, Hannu Poropudas wrote:
....
So linear extrapolated fossil data tries to tell
that perhaps Earth and Moon formed as a planet
couple ?


Too much difference in densities for that to be the case, or be the complete answer.

Also, we have tidal rhythmite data that gives us length-of-day and length-of-month data, up to about 2.2 billion years ago. That and "conservation of angular momentum", should help you evaluate your claims.

Papers like:
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/1.../97GL00234/pdf

David A. Smith
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Compelling new data that chemical and fossil evidence of ancientmicrobial life on Mars Raymond Yohros Amateur Astronomy 0 November 29th 09 05:21 PM
Compelling new data that chemical and fossil evidence of ancientmicrobial life on Mars Raymond Yohros Amateur Astronomy 0 November 28th 09 05:44 AM
Testing one stromatolite data from China with my linear extrapolationof Pannella's fossil points mathematician Astronomy Misc 2 March 26th 09 06:32 AM
Testing some ancient time data points with extrapolated Pannella'sfossil time data mathematician Astronomy Misc 1 January 21st 09 07:19 AM
Some Linear Extrapolations of Pannella’s Fossil Time Data for Test Purposes mathematician Astronomy Misc 1 January 19th 09 07:03 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:56 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 SpaceBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.