|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
So, has Orion been cancelled or not?
I know Mr Obama has said this-and-that, but what's actually happening? If
it is cancelled, is the STS going to be kept in service? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
So, has Orion been cancelled or not?
Alan Erskine wrote:
I know Mr Obama has said this-and-that, but what's actually happening? The president's budget for FY11 proposes to cancel all of Constellation, including Orion. However, Congress must authorize this and appropriate funds. Until the end of FY10, Constellation is still authorized and funded and work is continuing. If it is cancelled, is the STS going to be kept in service? No. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
So, has Orion been cancelled or not?
On Fri, 02 Apr 2010 08:36:32 GMT, "Alan Erskine"
wrote: I know Mr Obama has said this-and-that, but what's actually happening? If it is cancelled, is the STS going to be kept in service? President Obama's budget proposal cancels Constellation in favor of technology development and commercial transport. But this proposal went over like a lead balloon in Congress, which has to approve it. So exactly what is currently happening is anybody's guess. It seems pretty certain that Constellation is dead. What is less certain is what, if anything will replace it. The President didn't say, and NASA Administrator Bolden seemed to have been taken completely by surprise, offering almost no details about the new NASA direction. This has led to criticism that NASA will be left hugely vulnerable to slashed budgets in coming years, since it will have no goal to justify the technology development investment. And many space supporters clearly remember then-Senator Obama announcing his plan to cancel Constellation in order to fund education initiatives. The President did not cut NASA's budget this year, but his ill-defined plan for NASA makes it incredibly easy to do so next year and for the rest of his Administration. The President will visit Kennedy Space Center in mid-April, evidently attempting to mend fences. Fairly or not, the headline message from the President's budget proposal was "Obama kills manned spaceflight" and while he didn't win the KSC area in 2008, he's now persona-non-grata in Central Florida. So what will the President announce at KSC? A major change? Some sort of compromise plan seems likely. Would the President go to KSC during an active shuttle mission to simply say "This is what we're doing. The unemployment office is on 5th Street?" Rumor is that he'll extend Shuttle through STS-135, but they're still just rumors. Some alliances in Congress are pushing for Shuttle-derived vehicles to continue in some form, perhaps Ares, perhaps DIRECT, perhaps something else. From where the funding will come and what will be launched on this vehicle are equally vague. The Orion spacecraft has been cancelled as a NASA project (pending Congressional approval) but there is reason to believe Lockheed-Martin will continue to program as a commercial vehicle launched on Atlas, to compete with SpaceX, DreamChaser, and Boeing's commercial proposal. Given SpaceX's history of exploding rockets, it is certainly possible that Commercial Orion could beat Manned Dragon into space. Brian |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
So, has Orion been cancelled or not?
Brian Thorn wrote:
Given SpaceX's history of exploding rockets, it is certainly possible that Commercial Orion could beat Manned Dragon into space. Now, perhaps you are giving SpaceX too much credit - they only managed to get one rocket (first Falcon 1) to actually explode right?-) And IIRC even that was only upon impact with the Earth - I don't think they've managed to get any to actually explode in mid-flight. rick jones -- I don't interest myself in "why." I think more often in terms of "when," sometimes "where;" always "how much." - Joubert these opinions are mine, all mine; HP might not want them anyway... feel free to post, OR email to rick.jones2 in hp.com but NOT BOTH... |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
So, has Orion been cancelled or not?
On Fri, 2 Apr 2010 23:10:34 +0000 (UTC), Rick Jones
wrote: Now, perhaps you are giving SpaceX too much credit - they only managed to get one rocket (first Falcon 1) to actually explode right?-) And IIRC even that was only upon impact with the Earth - I don't think they've managed to get any to actually explode in mid-flight. Details, details! Brian |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Observing Cancelled | Davoud[_1_] | Amateur Astronomy | 22 | December 10th 09 06:49 PM |
P.Constellation will be cancelled | Jörg | Space Shuttle | 3 | August 14th 08 07:59 PM |
should space shuttle be cancelled? | John Thingstad | Policy | 89 | August 16th 05 07:02 AM |
Why Hubble was cancelled, and what to do now | Greg Kuperberg | Policy | 36 | February 9th 04 10:43 PM |
A new and different "What If" -- WI N1/L3 program not cancelled | Ami Silberman | History | 64 | December 29th 03 06:19 PM |