A Space & astronomy forum. SpaceBanter.com

Go Back   Home » SpaceBanter.com forum » Astronomy and Astrophysics » Amateur Astronomy
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

galileo galilei - dates to confirm



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old September 11th 06, 11:19 PM posted to sci.astro.amateur
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

Hello,

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610. OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...

If I simulate the sky at that time, of Firenze, arcetri, we discover that in
Jan-April 1610 Venus was in the East, 10° over the horizon with 80%+
illuminated, thus very small, and at the end in the rays of sun. hard to
imagine that he observed it at that time. It nevertheless could have did it.
On the other hand, at the autumn 1609 venus shows a fine crescent, and was
higher in the sky of the morning
Idem from October 1610 but, this time in the eve.

However it would have published his Siderius Nuncius in March 1610 (also to
re-confirm).
Impossible thus that he observed the beautiful crescent of venus before
publishing his book.

It was thus to have written his explanation and signed the "go for
printing", say at least 1 month before, in February
If one assumes that it was very smart, it obviously could have interpreted
the phases right between the invention of his scope and February 1610.
But that leaves him just a few weeks, and in counting on clear sky every
days, to discover the phases and its explanations, under bad seeing, without
speaking about his optics....

The book having been published in March, he would thus have observed Venus
at the worst moment of its phase Or he had to develop his scope in 1609...
But here also, the first drafts of Giovanni Battista della Porta were
published in August 1609... (to confirm as well). But that of Galileo would
not have been invented yet at that time.

That would tend to confirm that Galileo would have discovered the Venus
phases at a time it had a small diameter ( 15-12" if I remember well) under
very difficult conditions (both hardware and astronomical). The discovery
would all the more be deserving.
But is this well at that time that all that was held ?

Who could find me the exact dates (invention of Galileo's scope, 1st obs.,
obser. of Venus phases, publication of Messenger, etc)

Thanks in avdance

Thierry
http://www.astrosurf.org/lombry


  #2  
Old September 11th 06, 11:43 PM posted to sci.astro.amateur
OG
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 780
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm


Thierry wrote in message ...
Hello,

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610. OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...


Looks like the dates may be in error
Wikipedia
"Based only on sketchy descriptions of the telescope, invented in the
Netherlands in 1608, Galileo made one with about 8x magnification, and then
made improved models up to about 20x. On August 25, 1609, he demonstrated
his first telescope to Venetian lawmakers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo#Astronomy

If I simulate the sky at that time, of Firenze, arcetri, we discover that
in Jan-April 1610 Venus was in the East, 10° over the horizon with 80%+
illuminated, thus very small, and at the end in the rays of sun. hard to
imagine that he observed it at that time. It nevertheless could have did
it.
On the other hand, at the autumn 1609 venus shows a fine crescent, and was
higher in the sky of the morning


Good work, and could well suggest that he observed Venus in Autumn 1609
rather than early in 1610.


  #3  
Old September 12th 06, 12:00 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm


"OG" wrote in message
...

Thierry wrote in message ...
Hello,

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610.
OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...


Looks like the dates may be in error
Wikipedia


Not sure that wikipedia is a formal source of information
It will be not the first time that i correct data because references or
commentaries are not accurate, mix with rumor, etc.
I am agree that there are a lot of good things on wikipedia, I work on it as
well, but I don't consider it as an official source.
better to go to the museum of science of firenze, don't you think...

Thierry

"Based only on sketchy descriptions of the telescope, invented in the
Netherlands in 1608, Galileo made one with about 8x magnification, and
then made improved models up to about 20x. On August 25, 1609, he
demonstrated his first telescope to Venetian lawmakers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo#Astronomy

If I simulate the sky at that time, of Firenze, arcetri, we discover that
in Jan-April 1610 Venus was in the East, 10° over the horizon with 80%+
illuminated, thus very small, and at the end in the rays of sun. hard to
imagine that he observed it at that time. It nevertheless could have did
it.
On the other hand, at the autumn 1609 venus shows a fine crescent, and
was higher in the sky of the morning


Good work, and could well suggest that he observed Venus in Autumn 1609
rather than early in 1610.




  #4  
Old September 12th 06, 12:07 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm


"OG" wrote in message
...

Thierry wrote in message ...
Hello,

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610.
OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...


Looks like the dates may be in error
Wikipedia
"Based only on sketchy descriptions of the telescope, invented in the
Netherlands in 1608, Galileo made one with about 8x magnification, and
then made improved models up to about 20x. On August 25, 1609, he
demonstrated his first telescope to Venetian lawmakers."


Right. My mistake. I reread , my notes (I always wonder of the number of
information i found on my own site and that I have forgotten, of almost).
Hopefully there is a search engine....
Galileo seems have demonstrated his scope already on August 21. Its
magnification was 3x.
Remain to confirm the first observation of venus and with what scope

Thierry



  #5  
Old September 12th 06, 03:35 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
robert casey
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 790
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610

Heard that Galileo didn't invent the telescope, but was the first to
look at objects in the sky as a scientist. Others who had telescopes
for looking for ships and such probably took a peak at the Moon but
never did anything with those observations.

Also heard that the scope Galileo had was a real POS, and he would have
loved to have gotten his hands on one of our Christmas gift trash scopes
from WalMart. Even though those are POS's, they'd better his POS...
  #6  
Old September 12th 06, 03:46 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
William Hamblen
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 343
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

On 2006-09-11, Thierry Thierry wrote:

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610. OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...

If I simulate the sky at that time, of Firenze, arcetri, we discover that in
Jan-April 1610 Venus was in the East, 10° over the horizon with 80%+
illuminated, thus very small, and at the end in the rays of sun. hard to
imagine that he observed it at that time. It nevertheless could have did it.
On the other hand, at the autumn 1609 venus shows a fine crescent, and was
higher in the sky of the morning
Idem from October 1610 but, this time in the eve.

However it would have published his Siderius Nuncius in March 1610 (also to
re-confirm).
Impossible thus that he observed the beautiful crescent of venus before
publishing his book.

It was thus to have written his explanation and signed the "go for
printing", say at least 1 month before, in February
If one assumes that it was very smart, it obviously could have interpreted
the phases right between the invention of his scope and February 1610.
But that leaves him just a few weeks, and in counting on clear sky every
days, to discover the phases and its explanations, under bad seeing, without
speaking about his optics....

The book having been published in March, he would thus have observed Venus
at the worst moment of its phase Or he had to develop his scope in 1609...
But here also, the first drafts of Giovanni Battista della Porta were
published in August 1609... (to confirm as well). But that of Galileo would
not have been invented yet at that time.

That would tend to confirm that Galileo would have discovered the Venus
phases at a time it had a small diameter ( 15-12" if I remember well) under
very difficult conditions (both hardware and astronomical). The discovery
would all the more be deserving.
But is this well at that time that all that was held ?

Who could find me the exact dates (invention of Galileo's scope, 1st obs.,
obser. of Venus phases, publication of Messenger, etc)


The phases of Venus are in "Dialog Concerning the Two Chief
World Systems", which printed in 1632, and aren't in "Starry
Messenger", which was printed in 1610. There are fairly recent
English translations of both (Stillman & Van Helden).

I've got the Reston bio of Galileo around here somewhere. As
best as I remember, Galileo made a telescope sometime in 1609,
not long after news of the invention reached him.

Bud
  #7  
Old September 12th 06, 03:53 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
Llanzlan Klazmon
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 122
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

Thierry wrote in :


"OG" wrote in message
...

Thierry wrote in message ...
Hello,

A question about historical truth.
It is said that Galileo discovered the phases of Venus phases in 1610.
OK.
It is also said that he invented his scope only in 1610
Two dates to be confirmed, and if possible in the month close...


Looks like the dates may be in error
Wikipedia


Not sure that wikipedia is a formal source of information
It will be not the first time that i correct data because references or
commentaries are not accurate, mix with rumor, etc.
I am agree that there are a lot of good things on wikipedia, I work on
it as well, but I don't consider it as an official source.
better to go to the museum of science of firenze, don't you think...

Thierry


True but good Wikipedia articles should give references to primary sources.

Klazmon.



"Based only on sketchy descriptions of the telescope, invented in the
Netherlands in 1608, Galileo made one with about 8x magnification, and
then made improved models up to about 20x. On August 25, 1609, he
demonstrated his first telescope to Venetian lawmakers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo#Astronomy

If I simulate the sky at that time, of Firenze, arcetri, we discover
that in Jan-April 1610 Venus was in the East, 10° over the horizon
with 80%+ illuminated, thus very small, and at the end in the rays of
sun. hard to imagine that he observed it at that time. It nevertheless
could have did it.
On the other hand, at the autumn 1609 venus shows a fine crescent, and
was higher in the sky of the morning


Good work, and could well suggest that he observed Venus in Autumn 1609
rather than early in 1610.






  #8  
Old September 12th 06, 05:11 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
canopus56[_1_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 556
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

Thierry wrote:
snip.
Remain to confirm the first observation of venus and with what scope
Thierry


You might find these pages of interest in Pope's and Mosher's project -


WHAT GALILEO SAW
http://www.pacifier.com/~tpope/Photo...rison_Page.htm

VENUS THROUGH THE GALILEAN TELESCOPE
http://www.pacifier.com/~tpope/Venus_Page.htm

CCD IMAGES FROM A GALILEAN TELESCOPE
http://www.pacifier.com/~tpope/index.htm

- Canopus56

P.S. - Mosher and Pope note that the Venus drawings were first
reproduced in a plate in Galieo's _Il Saggiatore_ (1623). Mosher and
Pope also note that: "Galileo made many careful observations of the
phases of Venus, yet we do not know of any manuscript pages containing
the original drawings from which the plate was made."

Galileo may have made his Venus observations at anytime between 1610
and 1623.

  #9  
Old September 12th 06, 05:33 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
Ernie Wright
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 50
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

Thierry wrote:

Who could find me the exact dates (invention of Galileo's scope, 1st
obs., obser. of Venus phases, publication of Messenger, etc)


He observed the phases of Venus about eight months *after* he published
Sidereus Nuncius.

Aug 1609 - completed and demonstrated a 9x instrument
Nov 1609 - completed a 20x instrument and began observing the sky
Mar 1610 - published Sidereus Nuncius
Nov 1610 - began observing Venus
Dec 1610 - announced observation of Venus phases

Galileo demonstrated the 9x telescope to the Senate of Venice on 23
August 1609. (Galileo describes the demonstration in a 29 August 1609
letter which says, "...it has been 6 days since...") They observed
ships at sea, not the sky.

The letter at the beginning of Sidereus Nuncius dedicating the book to
Cosimo II de Medici is dated 12 March 1610.

Galileo announced his observation of the phases of Venus in a letter to
Giuliano de Medici dated 11 December 1610. He hid the announcement in
the form of an anagram,

Haec immatura a me iam frustra leguntur o y

which when unscrambled is

Cynthiae figuras aemulatur mater amorum
The mother of love emulates the figures of Cynthia
Venus has phases like the Moon

This is all from Albert Van Helden's English translation of Sidereus
Nuncius.

- Ernie http://home.comcast.net/~erniew

  #10  
Old September 12th 06, 07:17 AM posted to sci.astro.amateur
Brian Tung[_1_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 755
Default galileo galilei - dates to confirm

robert casey wrote:
Also heard that the scope Galileo had was a real POS, and he would have
loved to have gotten his hands on one of our Christmas gift trash scopes
from WalMart. Even though those are POS's, they'd better his POS...


As I understand it, it wasn't the execution so much as the design. It
had inherent aberrations, but the scopes he produced performed about as
well as a modern example of the same design would. There was a recent
article in Sky and Telescope or Night Sky about this.

--
Brian Tung
The Astronomy Corner at http://astro.isi.edu/
Unofficial C5+ Home Page at http://astro.isi.edu/c5plus/
The PleiadAtlas Home Page at http://astro.isi.edu/pleiadatlas/
My Own Personal FAQ (SAA) at http://astro.isi.edu/reference/faq.html
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
28 December 2005 : New step for the Galileo System POLE STAR Policy 2 December 30th 05 12:24 PM
First Galileo satellite on orbit to demonstrate key technologies(Forwarded) Andrew Yee News 0 December 30th 05 02:15 AM
Galileo End of Mission Status Ron Baalke History 65 October 30th 03 03:31 PM
Galileo End of Mission Status Ron Baalke Astronomy Misc 15 October 10th 03 04:19 AM
The Final Day on Galileo Ron Baalke Science 0 September 19th 03 07:32 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:56 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 SpaceBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.