|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
druids' knowledge of astronomy?
On 14/02/2013 15:17, Davoud wrote:
Martin Brown: Given how terrifying a solar eclipse would be to an ancient culture... Davoud: I don't take that as a given. In the absence of written records I have no idea how certain ancient cultures reacted to eclipses. In those cases where written records exist--Sumer, Egypt, China--there is no evidence that scientists were terrified by solar eclipses. Martin Brown: That figures since back then there were no scientists at all. There were the forerunners of philosophers, leaders and priests. Being able to predict the date and time of eclipses had *very* high status... You define scientist your way, I define it my way, which seems to be a bit more flexible than your way. Ancients who were accurately predicting eclipses, whether they were shamans or priests or forerunners, were scientists in my view. Some of these people were aware of what causes eclipses, some knew to within considerable precision the circumference of the Earth. I call the methods they used to measure and deduce, "science." They and their descendants upto at least Newton and perhaps a bit later would have described themselves as natural philosophers. They observed what happened and tried to explain it within the frameworks available. Empirical experimentalism wasn't as highly prized as received wisdom and as a result Aristotle's false claims that in humans males had more teeth than females and heavier objects fall faster than lighter ones survived unchallenged until the enlightenment and the forerunners of modern scientific experimentalists like Galileo and Tycho started actually testing them systematically. -- Regards, Martin Brown |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
druids' knowledge of astronomy?
On 14/02/2013 11:44, Lord Androcles, Zeroth Earl of Medway wrote:
"Martin Brown" wrote in message ... On 13/02/2013 01:24, Davoud wrote: Martin Brown: Given how terrifying a solar eclipse would be to an ancient culture... I don't take that as a given. In the absence of written records I have no idea how certain ancient cultures reacted to eclipses. In those cases where written records exist--Sumer, Egypt, China--there is no evidence that scientists were terrified by solar eclipses. That figures since back then there were no scientists at all. There were the forerunners of philosophers, leaders and priests. ================================================== ====== Amazing... the forerunners of this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism The Greek antikythera mechanism was about 2000 years old. We were discussing the culture that built Stone Henge which is more like 4-5000 years old and left no written record. I agree with you that the wet British climate is not conducive to finding any even if there was something at the time. But we can hope one day an archeologist will stumble upon something. In the meantime various experimental archeologists have tried their hand at doing the various stages to quarry and erect a monolith using the best guess at technologies of the stoneage. were dressed in leotards and clubbed women over the head before dragging them off to their caves... right, Brown? Pythagoras, Plato, Archimedes were not scientists... right, Brown? Scientists have white lab coats, pocket protectors and thick glasses... right, Brown? No. They were philosophers, mathematicians and natural philosophers and that is pretty much how they would have seen themselves at the time. Archimedes was also a very impressive inventor and engineer as well. The first experimental scientists as we would recognise the term were the likes of Galileo and Tycho who no longer took the word of Aristotle as an absolute truth. They did experiments to try and break the status quo. Prior to that the onus was learning all existing knowledge and then finding new things to add to the body of knowledge. -- Regards, Martin Brown |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
druids' knowledge of astronomy?
"Martin Brown" wrote in message ...
On 14/02/2013 11:44, Lord Androcles, Zeroth Earl of Medway wrote: "Martin Brown" wrote in message ... On 13/02/2013 01:24, Davoud wrote: Martin Brown: Given how terrifying a solar eclipse would be to an ancient culture... I don't take that as a given. In the absence of written records I have no idea how certain ancient cultures reacted to eclipses. In those cases where written records exist--Sumer, Egypt, China--there is no evidence that scientists were terrified by solar eclipses. That figures since back then there were no scientists at all. There were the forerunners of philosophers, leaders and priests. ================================================== ====== Amazing... the forerunners of this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism The Greek antikythera mechanism was about 2000 years old. We were discussing the culture that built Stone Henge which is more like 4-5000 years old and left no written record. I agree with you that the wet British climate is not conducive to finding any even if there was something at the time. But we can hope one day an archeologist will stumble upon something. In the meantime various experimental archeologists have tried their hand at doing the various stages to quarry and erect a monolith using the best guess at technologies of the stoneage. ================================================== == The "stoneage" is at least 40,000 years old, an ice age has come and gone since men and women created European cave art. The whole of Egyptian, Hittite and Babylonian civilisations have come and gone in a tenth of "the stoneage". For all we know whole cities the size of St Petersburg, Berlin, London, Paris, Oslo etc. could have been buried and completely destroyed by mile high glaciers while the Sahara was a garden of Eden. Whole civilisations come and gone, lost forever. The North American Aborigines that we call "Indians" had a stone-age culture until 150 years ago. Zimbabwe is an ancient city in Africa, Ankhor Wat an ancient city in Asia. What "archaeologists" know of culture is only the most recent past, nothing of 10,000 or 20,000 or 30,000 years ago. Yes, we know Phil Harding likes flint knapping to fashion arrowheads and Mick Aston is thrilled by the foundations of Saxon chapels, but their actual knowledge is archeo-fiction rather than fact. Hill forts to keep out invading tribes, or to keep out invading bear, wolf and auroch, dangerous animals now extinct but once extant in Britain? I'm sorry, but I don't buy your theory of no writing 4-5000 years ago, or of solar eclipses terrifying anyone except Mick Aston, gung-ho on his religious beliefs. were dressed in leotards and clubbed women over the head before dragging them off to their caves... right, Brown? Pythagoras, Plato, Archimedes were not scientists... right, Brown? Scientists have white lab coats, pocket protectors and thick glasses... right, Brown? No. They were philosophers, mathematicians and natural philosophers and that is pretty much how they would have seen themselves at the time. Archimedes was also a very impressive inventor and engineer as well. ============================================== And their predecessors were illiterate louts with no writing who hid cowering under the straw mattress when the Moon hid the Sun? The first experimental scientists as we would recognise the term were the likes of Galileo and Tycho who no longer took the word of Aristotle as an absolute truth. They did experiments to try and break the status quo. Prior to that the onus was learning all existing knowledge and then finding new things to add to the body of knowledge. ================================================== What you are describing is 2000 year old Roman culture, heavy with conquest and religion, light on mathematics. Greek mathematics was shelved and forgotten, Arabian and Indian mathematics not understood. Roman Catholicism has NEVER been interested in finding new things to add to the body of knowledge, and that is the culture we've inherited. The builders of Stonehenge were scientists and intelligent enough to write. -- This message is brought to you from the keyboard of Lord Androcles, Zeroth Earl of Medway. When the fools chicken farmer Wilson and Van de faggot present an argument I cannot laugh at I'll retire from usenet. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
ancient druids' knowledge of astronomy? | David Dalton | Astronomy Misc | 5 | February 12th 13 04:03 AM |
Space art and knowledge | Dawid Michalczyk | Amateur Astronomy | 17 | February 3rd 09 06:01 AM |
My god, even our knowledge must die | nightbat | Misc | 1 | October 25th 06 12:05 PM |
knowledge is power | mostafa dia | Satellites | 3 | August 11th 04 07:17 AM |
knowledge is power | mostafa dia | SETI | 4 | August 7th 04 02:24 PM |