If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. 


Thread Tools  Display Modes 
#1




Effect of Moon's Gravity on Earth
"Cockpit Colin" writes:
"If the gravity of the moon can, from a quarter of a million km away, be strong enough to influence millions of tons of water (ie tides), would it be able to cause any apparant variation in a person's weight here on earth" Reason I ask is that at the moment I'm weighing myself daily  and I'm on a diet that's VERY consistent  and yet I often get variations on my (electronic) scales of up to 2 pounds / 1kg from day to day (even though I'm averaging several readings)  and was wondering if the moons gravity might be strong enough to induce even so much as a 1% error? No. Gravity obeys an inverse square law, i.e., doubling the distance decreases the strength of the "gravitation force" by a factor of four, tripling the distance decreases it by a factor of nine, etc. Rounding all figures to one significant digit to make them useless in case this is really a homework problem and not a question of mere idle curiosity, the Moon has a radius of a bit under 2000 km, and a mean distance of a bit under 400,000 km (neglecting the radius of the Earth, which is unimportant on this scale). Since the Moon is over 200 times farther than its radius, by the inverse square law its gravitation force, already only 1/6 that of Earth at its surface, would be reduced by a another factor of over 40,000, to less than one part in 200,000. This is many MANY times smaller than "one part in 100," which is what "1%" means. The above should be sufficient to answer your question if it is merely due to curiosity. If it is homework, you will need to look up the actual numbers and work out the answer for yourself.  Gordon D. Pusch perl e '$_ = \n"; s/NO\.//; s/SPAM\.//; print;' 
Ads 
#2




Effect of Moon's Gravity on Earth
JRS: In article , seen in
news:sci.space.science, Gordon D. Pusch [email protected] et.com posted at Tue, 23 Mar 2004 10:19:14 : "Cockpit Colin" writes: "If the gravity of the moon can, from a quarter of a million km away, be strong enough to influence millions of tons of water (ie tides), would it be able to cause any apparant variation in a person's weight here on earth" Not a quarter of a million km. Reason I ask is that at the moment I'm weighing myself daily  and I'm on a diet that's VERY consistent  and yet I often get variations on my (electronic) scales of up to 2 pounds / 1kg from day to day (even though I'm averaging several readings)  and was wondering if the moons gravity might be strong enough to induce even so much as a 1% error? No. Gravity obeys an inverse square law, i.e., doubling the distance decreases the strength of the "gravitation force" by a factor of four, tripling the distance decreases it by a factor of nine, etc. Rounding all figures to one significant digit to make them useless in case this is really a homework problem and not a question of mere idle curiosity, the Moon has a radius of a bit under 2000 km, and a mean distance of a bit under 400,000 km (neglecting the radius of the Earth, which is unimportant on this scale). Since the Moon is over 200 times farther than its radius, by the inverse square law its gravitation force, already only 1/6 that of Earth at its surface, would be reduced by a another factor of over 40,000, to less than one part in 200,000. This is many MANY times smaller than "one part in 100," which is what "1%" means. The above should be sufficient to answer your question if it is merely due to curiosity. If it is homework, you will need to look up the actual numbers and work out the answer for yourself. Correct result, but incorrect reasoning. The Moon does attract a person underneath it, but it also attracts the Earth. One needs to calculate, therefore, not the pull but the differential pull; the variation of the lunar gravitational field over the 4000 miles that separate the centre of a person from the centre of the Earth. The effect will therefore be much less than you calculate; by a factor of the order of (Moon's distance / Earth's radius), which is about 60, and perhaps another factor of the order of unity.  © John Stockton, Surrey, UK. / © Web URL:http://www.merlyn.demon.co.uk/  FAQish topics, acronyms, & links. Correct = 4line sig. separator as above, a line precisely " " (SoRFC1036) Do not Mail News to me. Before a reply, quote with "" or " " (SoRFC1036) 
#3




Effect of Moon's Gravity on Earth
Reason I ask is that at the moment I'm weighing myself daily  and I'm on a
diet that's VERY consistent  and yet I often get variations on my (electronic) scales of up to 2 pounds / 1kg from day to day (even though I'm averaging several readings)  and was wondering if the moons gravity might be strong enough to induce even so much as a 1% error? Its about .001%. Thats significant enough that a tidal correction must be made for prspecting by the gravity method. You'd see more change in your weight by weighing yourself in Kenya compared to Norway (several ounces) or at the bottom or top of Mt Everest (fraction of ounce). 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  


Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
NASA Celebrates Educational Benefits of Earth Science Week  Ron Baalke  Science  0  October 10th 03 04:14 PM 
Hubble Uncovers Smallest Moons Yet Seen Around Uranus  Ron Baalke  Science  11  October 10th 03 12:30 AM 
First Extrasolar Planets, Now Extrasolar Moons! (Eddington)  Ron Baalke  Science  0  October 8th 03 07:06 PM 
Oceanographers Catch First Wave Of Gravity Mission's Success  Ron Baalke  Science  13  August 7th 03 06:24 AM 
Ed Lu Letter from Space #6  Jacques van Oene  Space Station  0  July 4th 03 11:10 AM 