#14
|
|||
|
|||
"Kaido Kert" wrote in message om... "Christian Ramos" wrote in message ... There appears little room for payload now, so placing biologicals and associated life support on those payloads seems a bit ridiculous, I asked the same question in another online discussion, and got the number of around 50kg for one rat and its consumables for a six-month cruise, including associated equipment. I suspect its closer to 100 but still not prohibitely high. Hmm. I think that would be significant unless it was on its own mission. let alone the fact that you would have to go to mars to actually retreive the rats.. Additionally, rats arent really going to cut it in determining the effect on humans, plants and other species. Its not absolutely necessary to retrieve them, is it ? We could simply pack sufficient health monitoring equipment along. Of course, returning it back to earth and monitoring the long-term effects would be even better, so if you have a mars sample return mission, it would be perhaps possible to return biological experiments from martian orbit along with surface sample. I'm not aware of such equipment, you would probably have more luck utilising cell cultures and such, but again the data would only marginally be relevant. We're not talking about radiation as comes out of reactor core, it is a different thing. Obivously effects on humans would be far from certain with rat experiment, but we could be a lot more confident, after all we have used rats for such purposes for centuries. But packing a couple plants along would be a good idea of course, especially because those wouldnt cost much in a payload. We're probably, getting into the realms of where experts in the area need to comment, however, the documents I've read indicate this wouldnt be viable. It's more than monitoring their health, you want to see what damage is down for both different fluxes of radiation and accumulated forms of radiation. How would you match them. You could probably measure the radiation, a sophisticated thing when talking space operation, but how would you measure the impact on cells for each form, how would you determine the secondary effects and interations between various forms of damage and other biological processes, how would you differenatiate changes from radiation as opposed to gravity or environmental. Eventually some living organism is going to have to take the trip, and it would be kinda stupid to have the first human crew as test subjects. Why..I dont remember Nasa sending rats to the moon before the Apollo landing. But they put chimps in Mercury capsules, didnt they. US was in a race then and didnt have enough time to do it. Were there never plans to put animals on Surveyors ? Sure..But the Mercury capsules were LEO that is not that environment of outer space that the apollos encountered on the way to the moon. As for the data that was gathered, well I would guess it gave them a systems integration perspective, ie: does everything seem to work. Space was very much an unknown which probably drove the chimps and dogs in space, although, it's an interesting question, why did the chimp go into to space, was it just a conservative approach to validation or something else. I'm sure in one of the historical books I've read that the chimp decision was made by Von braun given his lack of confidence in the boosters, but I could be totally screwed up there, will have to dig them up once my "lab" is complete |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The Gravitational Instability Theory on the Formation of the Universe | Br Dan Izzo | Policy | 6 | September 7th 04 09:29 PM |
The Gravitational Instability Cosmological Theory | Br Dan Izzo | Astronomy Misc | 0 | August 31st 04 02:35 AM |
Interstellar radiation part of Mars challenge | Kent Betts | History | 0 | December 10th 03 05:37 AM |
Wich is the best Radiation Hull or Shield we can build for a spacecraft? | Steve Harris [email protected] | Science | 9 | October 28th 03 05:23 AM |
New NASA Facility Will Help Protect Space Crews From Radiation | Ron Baalke | Space Station | 0 | October 14th 03 04:23 PM |