|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Human vs. Robot Explorers! An Easy Debate to Win!
On Aug 21, 12:24*am, Fred J. McCall wrote:
Pat Flannery wrote: :Jeff Findley wrote: : : This is absolutely true. *Men in suits can do more in a day or two than : robotic probes can do in years. *Look at the distance that the Mars rovers : have traversed over their lifetimes and compare that to what was done on : manned lunar missions, specifically the ones which used the lunar rover. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Human vs. Robot Explorers! An Easy Debate to Win!
"Eric Chomko" wrote in message ... I'd be happy to see then bring home some Martian dirt first. Eric Exactly. Let's have a race! Starting now let's build a couple of nex-gen rovers, and a manned missions to the Moon then Mars. (which is their stated plan) I think the robots will win by about FORTY YEARS..give or take. Why anyone /interested in the scienctific aspect/ of exploration would prefer the long slow expensive route is beyond me. Why, so people like Buzz or Neal can wow us with their personal meanderings, cliched poems or 'modern' paintings from Mars? A sample return isn't needed, we can take the lab there instead. Much faster. From the Mars Science Labaratory page... APXS "The Alpha Particle X-Ray Spectrometer will measure the abundance of chemical elements in rocks and soils."...."Its sensor head is designed to be smaller than a soda can..." ChemMin "Designed to be about the size of a laptop computer inside a carrying case." ..."The Chemistry and Mineralogy instrument, or CheMin for short, will identify and measure the abundances of various minerals on Mars.' "To prepare rock samples for analysis, the rover will be able to drill into rocks, collect the resulting fine powder, sieve it, and deliver it to a sample holder. It will use a scoop for collecting soil...." "MAHLI will provide earthbound scientists with close-up views of the minerals, textures, and structures in martian rocks and the surface layer of rocky debris and dust. The self-focusing, roughly 4-centimeter-wide (1.5-inch-wide) camera will take color images of features as small as 12.5 micrometers, smaller than the diameter of a human hair." "The Mast Camera, or Mastcam for short, will take color images and color video footage of the Martian terrain. One of the two Mastcam camera systems has a moderate-resolution lens, similar to the Pancam on the Mars Exploration Rovers. The other camera system has a high-resolution lens in order to study the landscape far from the rover." RAD "The Radiation Assessment Detector (RAD) will be one of the first instruments sent to Mars specifically to prepare for future human exploration. The size of a small toaster or six-pack of soda,..." ChemCam "Looking at rocks and soils from a distance, ChemCam will fire a laser and analyze the elemental composition of vaporized materials from areas smaller than 1 millimeter on the surface of Martian rocks and soils." SAM "The Sample Analysis at Mars instrument suite will take up more than half the science payload on board the Mars Science Laboratory rover and feature chemical equipment found in many scientific laboratories on Earth. Provided by NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, Sample Analysis at Mars will search for compounds of the element carbon, including methane, that are associated with life and explore ways in which they are generated and destroyed in the martian ecosphere." DAN "...the Mars Science Laboratory rover will carry a pulsing neutron generator called the Dynamic Albedo of Neutrons that will be sensitive enough to detect water content as low as one-tenth of 1 percent and resolve layers of water and ice beneath the surface." http://marsprogram.jpl.nasa.gov/msl/...nts/index.html I find it telling that more than half the science payload is devoted to the search for life on Mars. Must be the idea of life on Mars is no longer the fringe view eh? And keep in mind the big question is about life elsewhere. The big draw or allure of Mars is in answering this most timeless question of all. Once that question is answered, the desire to go there will evapoarate. Just like interest in the Moon and Apollo evaporated directly after the successful landings |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Human vs. Robot Explorers! An Easy Debate to Win! | Jonathan | Policy | 48 | August 27th 09 06:25 PM |
Human vs. Robot Explorers! An Easy Debate to Win! | Jeff Findley | Space Shuttle | 3 | August 21st 09 08:12 PM |