|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Mining asteroids. Ridiculous
How, pray tell, with cruddy chemical rockets, could they possibly
entertain this idea? You might as well try to hack through kimberlite to find diamonds with a plastic shovel. One choice: Nuclear bomb propulsion and ships BIG enough to do the job, otherwise, forget it. 22 January 2013 Last updated at 11:39 ET New venture 'to mine asteroids' By Paul Rincon Science editor, BBC News website A new venture is joining the effort to extract mineral resources on asteroids. The announcement of plans by Deep Space Industries to exploit the rare metals present in the space rocks turns asteroid mining into a two- horse race. The other venture, Planetary Resources, went public with its proposals last year. Advocates of asteroid mining hope it could turn into a trillion-dollar business, but some scientists are highly sceptical of the idea. Deep Space Industries wants to send a fleet of asteroid-prospecting spacecraft out into the Solar System to hunt for resources. These spacecraft, which the company has dubbed "Fireflies", would use low-cost CubeSat components and benefit from discounted delivery to space by ride-sharing on the launch of larger communications satellites. The Fireflies would have a mass of about 55 lb (25 kg) and be launched for the first time in 2015 on journeys of two to six months. The company then wants to launch bigger spacecraft - which it calls "Dragonflies" - for round-trip visits that bring back samples. These expeditions would take two to four years, depending on the target, and would return 60 to 150 lbs of material from target asteroids. "Using resources harvested in space is the only way to afford permanent space development," said the company's chief executive David Gump. "More than 900 new asteroids that pass near Earth are discovered every year. They can be like the Iron Range of Minnesota was for the Detroit car industry last century - a key resource located near where it was needed. In this case, metals and fuel from asteroids can expand the in- space industries of this century." Asteroids could yield precious minerals such as gold, platinum and rare-Earth metals. But some are also thought to harbour water ice, which could be used as a raw material for the manufacture of rocket propellant or even breathable air. The other firm in the mining race, Planetary Resources, has backing from several billionaire investors, including Google's Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, software executive Charles Simonyi and filmmaker James Cameron. That company wants to start by launching orbiting telescopes that would identify suitable asteroid targets for mineral exploitation. However, some scientists struggle to see how cost-effective asteroid mining could be, even with the high value of gold and platinum. They point out that an upcoming Nasa mission to return just 60g (two ounces) of material from an asteroid will cost about $1bn. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Mining asteroids. Ridiculous
On 23/01/2013 01:37, RichA wrote:
How, pray tell, with cruddy chemical rockets, could they possibly entertain this idea? You might as well try to hack through kimberlite to find diamonds with a plastic shovel. One choice: Nuclear bomb propulsion and ships BIG enough to do the job, otherwise, forget it. Do you think anyone is going to licence a bunch of clueless Trekkies to use nuclear propulsion? This sounds more like some kind of advanced tax dodge or IPO scam than any serious attempt at space exploration. South Sea Bubble, Tulip Mania, DotCom Boom for the Trekkie generation. The best bet would be to hoover up any pretty nickel-iron meteors that come close enough but getting them back through the Earth's atmosphere will pose serious difficulties. I can't see any nations being willing to allow a bunch of modern day cowboys to hurl meteorites at them. Beyond pie in the sky. The present cost of robotic sample recovery is around $10bn/kg and there are no metals at that price or even close. The values of materials on other worlds will be completely different to on Earth since on Mars we really want water, oxygen and fuel. Gold, platinum and diamonds are of very limited usefulness in outer space. It is a long way to April the First but you have to wonder if the guy in charge isn't related for Forrest Gump "stupid is as stupid does". I wonder how the scheme works? Regards, Martin Brown 22 January 2013 Last updated at 11:39 ET New venture 'to mine asteroids' By Paul Rincon Science editor, BBC News website A new venture is joining the effort to extract mineral resources on asteroids. The announcement of plans by Deep Space Industries to exploit the rare metals present in the space rocks turns asteroid mining into a two- horse race. The other venture, Planetary Resources, went public with its proposals last year. Advocates of asteroid mining hope it could turn into a trillion-dollar business, but some scientists are highly sceptical of the idea. Deep Space Industries wants to send a fleet of asteroid-prospecting spacecraft out into the Solar System to hunt for resources. These spacecraft, which the company has dubbed "Fireflies", would use low-cost CubeSat components and benefit from discounted delivery to space by ride-sharing on the launch of larger communications satellites. The Fireflies would have a mass of about 55 lb (25 kg) and be launched for the first time in 2015 on journeys of two to six months. The company then wants to launch bigger spacecraft - which it calls "Dragonflies" - for round-trip visits that bring back samples. These expeditions would take two to four years, depending on the target, and would return 60 to 150 lbs of material from target asteroids. "Using resources harvested in space is the only way to afford permanent space development," said the company's chief executive David Gump. "More than 900 new asteroids that pass near Earth are discovered every year. They can be like the Iron Range of Minnesota was for the Detroit car industry last century - a key resource located near where it was needed. In this case, metals and fuel from asteroids can expand the in- space industries of this century." Asteroids could yield precious minerals such as gold, platinum and rare-Earth metals. But some are also thought to harbour water ice, which could be used as a raw material for the manufacture of rocket propellant or even breathable air. The other firm in the mining race, Planetary Resources, has backing from several billionaire investors, including Google's Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, software executive Charles Simonyi and filmmaker James Cameron. That company wants to start by launching orbiting telescopes that would identify suitable asteroid targets for mineral exploitation. However, some scientists struggle to see how cost-effective asteroid mining could be, even with the high value of gold and platinum. They point out that an upcoming Nasa mission to return just 60g (two ounces) of material from an asteroid will cost about $1bn. -- Regards, Martin Brown |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Mining asteroids. Ridiculous
On Jan 23, 9:26*am, Martin Brown
wrote: On 23/01/2013 01:37, RichA wrote: How, pray tell, with cruddy chemical rockets, could they possibly entertain this idea? *You might as well try to hack through kimberlite to find diamonds with a plastic shovel. *One choice: *Nuclear bomb propulsion and ships BIG enough to do the job, otherwise, forget it. Do you think anyone is going to licence a bunch of clueless Trekkies to use nuclear propulsion? This sounds more like some kind of advanced tax dodge or IPO scam than any serious attempt at space exploration. South Sea Bubble, Tulip Mania, DotCom Boom for the Trekkie generation. The best bet would be to hoover up any pretty nickel-iron meteors that come close enough but getting them back through the Earth's atmosphere will pose serious difficulties. I can't see any nations being willing to allow a bunch of modern day cowboys to hurl meteorites at them. Beyond pie in the sky. The present cost of robotic sample recovery is around $10bn/kg and there are no metals at that price or even close. The values of materials on other worlds will be completely different to on Earth since on Mars we really want water, oxygen and fuel. Gold, platinum and diamonds are of very limited usefulness in outer space. It is a long way to April the First but you have to wonder if the guy in charge isn't related for Forrest Gump "stupid is as stupid does". I wonder how the scheme works? Regards, Martin Brown * 22 January 2013 Last updated at 11:39 ET New venture 'to mine asteroids' By Paul Rincon Science editor, BBC News website A new venture is joining the effort to extract mineral resources on asteroids. The announcement of plans by Deep Space Industries to exploit the rare metals present in the space rocks turns asteroid mining into a two- horse race. The other venture, Planetary Resources, went public with its proposals last year. Advocates of asteroid mining hope it could turn into a trillion-dollar business, but some scientists are highly sceptical of the idea. Deep Space Industries wants to send a fleet of asteroid-prospecting spacecraft out into the Solar System to hunt for resources. These spacecraft, which the company has dubbed "Fireflies", would use low-cost CubeSat components and benefit from discounted delivery to space by ride-sharing on the launch of larger communications satellites. The Fireflies would have a mass of about 55 lb (25 kg) and be launched for the first time in 2015 on journeys of two to six months. The company then wants to launch bigger spacecraft - which it calls "Dragonflies" - for round-trip visits that bring back samples. These expeditions would take two to four years, depending on the target, and would return 60 to 150 lbs of material from target asteroids. "Using resources harvested in space is the only way to afford permanent space development," said the company's chief executive David Gump. "More than 900 new asteroids that pass near Earth are discovered every year. They can be like the Iron Range of Minnesota was for the Detroit car industry last century - a key resource located near where it was needed. In this case, metals and fuel from asteroids can expand the in- space industries of this century." Asteroids could yield precious minerals such as gold, platinum and rare-Earth metals. But some are also thought to harbour water ice, which could be used as a raw material for the manufacture of rocket propellant or even breathable air. The other firm in the mining race, Planetary Resources, has backing from several billionaire investors, including Google's Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, software executive Charles Simonyi and filmmaker James Cameron. That company wants to start by launching orbiting telescopes that would identify suitable asteroid targets for mineral exploitation. However, some scientists struggle to see how cost-effective asteroid mining could be, even with the high value of gold and platinum. They point out that an upcoming Nasa mission to return just 60g (two ounces) of material from an asteroid will cost about $1bn. -- Regards, Martin Brown Listen to yourself,the longest running soap opera isn't 'As The World Turns',it is the comedic empirical soap opera using a turning homocentric framework that stupidly equates a rotating celestial sphere with a rotating Earth. The software guys pay you so little heed these days that they invented their own stories to abolish a leap second where the Earth turns once in exactly 24 hours back in the year 1820 - "At the time of the dinosaurs, Earth completed one rotation in about 23 hours," says MacMillan, who is a member of the VLBI team at NASA Goddard. "In the year 1820, a rotation took exactly 24 hours, or 86,400 standard seconds. Since 1820, the mean solar day has increased by about 2.5 milliseconds." NASA Backyard astronomy indeed !,more like backward astronomy and the thing about it is that is is all so easy to correct and set straight a stable astronomical narrative. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Oriel 13th attampt to extract an answer
It doesn't seem long since Oriel36 said he was leaving the group. As I
have said before his mental health issues prevent him from doing so - he quite literally cannot help himself from posting minor variations of same old rubbish again and again. Notice how carefully Oriel, over a period of some years, has avoided explaining exactly where his views and the views of other members of this group differ. He writes whole paragraphs - sometimes nultiple paragraphs - hundreds of times a year but refuses to explain something as basic as this. He also refuses to answer any questions designed to identify what the difference might be. As an example - Oriel, if you look due south at midnight on July 1st and again at midnight on January 1st of the next year will you see the same stars in the same places. Yes or no? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Oriel 13th attampt to extract an answer
On Jan 23, 3:00*pm, Martin Nicholson
wrote: As an example - Oriel, if you look due south at midnight on July 1st and again at midnight on January 1st of the next year will you see the same stars in the same places. Yes or no? You know,you designed a 'game' a few years ago that you didn't even have to play and you lost and I still get a chuckle out of people who set a snare and are caught in it themselves but that in itself means nothing - the Universe is enormous,life is short and the life of an astronomer is spent making sense of the connection between the individual and the Universal and people should really try it sometime. There is daily rotational South and then there is ecliptic South ,the two combine to generate variations in the natural noon cycle,the seasons and all the other productive effects arising from cyclical dynamics but unfortunately there are possibly the dullest people on the planet still attached to right ascension modeling and who can't seem to make sense of the ecliptic axis and the turning of a planet to the Sun and stars as a components of its orbital motion - http://www.daviddarling.info/images/...gs_changes.jpg You are so fond of attaching Kepler's name to Newton but like all astronomers with common sense,Kepler took the only possible view of lunar orbital behavior and a non rotating moon.If people are paid to be astronomers it is time for them to act like astronomers,as for you,well you are simply a uisance like the other guy but at least serve the purpose of thread continuity so at least that is some consolation for you.You actually have to be alive,intelligent and interested in astronomy to be an astronomer and that I have rarely seen in these forums and brilliant information goes unused and ignored. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Mining asteroids. Ridiculous
On Jan 23, 4:26*am, Martin Brown
wrote: On 23/01/2013 01:37, RichA wrote: How, pray tell, with cruddy chemical rockets, could they possibly entertain this idea? *You might as well try to hack through kimberlite to find diamonds with a plastic shovel. *One choice: *Nuclear bomb propulsion and ships BIG enough to do the job, otherwise, forget it. Do you think anyone is going to licence a bunch of clueless Trekkies to use nuclear propulsion? This sounds more like some kind of advanced tax dodge or IPO scam than any serious attempt at space exploration. South Sea Bubble, Tulip Mania, DotCom Boom for the Trekkie generation. The best bet would be to hoover up any pretty nickel-iron meteors that come close enough but getting them back through the Earth's atmosphere will pose serious difficulties. I can't see any nations being willing to allow a bunch of modern day cowboys to hurl meteorites at them. Beyond pie in the sky. The present cost of robotic sample recovery is around $10bn/kg and there are no metals at that price or even close. The values of materials on other worlds will be completely different to on Earth since on Mars we really want water, oxygen and fuel. Gold, platinum and diamonds are of very limited usefulness in outer space. It is a long way to April the First but you have to wonder if the guy in charge isn't related for Forrest Gump "stupid is as stupid does". I wonder how the scheme works? Regards, Martin Brown * 22 January 2013 Last updated at 11:39 ET New venture 'to mine asteroids' By Paul Rincon Science editor, BBC News website A new venture is joining the effort to extract mineral resources on asteroids. The announcement of plans by Deep Space Industries to exploit the rare metals present in the space rocks turns asteroid mining into a two- horse race. The other venture, Planetary Resources, went public with its proposals last year. Advocates of asteroid mining hope it could turn into a trillion-dollar business, but some scientists are highly sceptical of the idea. Deep Space Industries wants to send a fleet of asteroid-prospecting spacecraft out into the Solar System to hunt for resources. These spacecraft, which the company has dubbed "Fireflies", would use low-cost CubeSat components and benefit from discounted delivery to space by ride-sharing on the launch of larger communications satellites. The Fireflies would have a mass of about 55 lb (25 kg) and be launched for the first time in 2015 on journeys of two to six months. The company then wants to launch bigger spacecraft - which it calls "Dragonflies" - for round-trip visits that bring back samples. These expeditions would take two to four years, depending on the target, and would return 60 to 150 lbs of material from target asteroids. "Using resources harvested in space is the only way to afford permanent space development," said the company's chief executive David Gump. "More than 900 new asteroids that pass near Earth are discovered every year. They can be like the Iron Range of Minnesota was for the Detroit car industry last century - a key resource located near where it was needed. In this case, metals and fuel from asteroids can expand the in- space industries of this century." Asteroids could yield precious minerals such as gold, platinum and rare-Earth metals. But some are also thought to harbour water ice, which could be used as a raw material for the manufacture of rocket propellant or even breathable air. The other firm in the mining race, Planetary Resources, has backing from several billionaire investors, including Google's Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, software executive Charles Simonyi and filmmaker James Cameron. That company wants to start by launching orbiting telescopes that would identify suitable asteroid targets for mineral exploitation. However, some scientists struggle to see how cost-effective asteroid mining could be, even with the high value of gold and platinum. They point out that an upcoming Nasa mission to return just 60g (two ounces) of material from an asteroid will cost about $1bn. They're going to sample them, then tow the asteroid back with a bigger ship and drop it in the shallow part of an ocean. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Mining asteroids. Ridiculous
On Jan 22, 5:37*pm, RichA wrote:
How, pray tell, with cruddy chemical rockets, could they possibly entertain this idea? *You might as well try to hack through kimberlite to find diamonds with a plastic shovel. *One choice: *Nuclear bomb propulsion and ships BIG enough to do the job, otherwise, forget it. *22 January 2013 Last updated at 11:39 ET New venture 'to mine asteroids' By Paul Rincon Science editor, BBC News website A new venture is joining the effort to extract mineral resources on asteroids. The announcement of plans by Deep Space Industries to exploit the rare metals present in the space rocks turns asteroid mining into a two- horse race. The other venture, Planetary Resources, went public with its proposals last year. Advocates of asteroid mining hope it could turn into a trillion-dollar business, but some scientists are highly sceptical of the idea. Deep Space Industries wants to send a fleet of asteroid-prospecting spacecraft out into the Solar System to hunt for resources. These spacecraft, which the company has dubbed "Fireflies", would use low-cost CubeSat components and benefit from discounted delivery to space by ride-sharing on the launch of larger communications satellites. The Fireflies would have a mass of about 55 lb (25 kg) and be launched for the first time in 2015 on journeys of two to six months. The company then wants to launch bigger spacecraft - which it calls "Dragonflies" - for round-trip visits that bring back samples. These expeditions would take two to four years, depending on the target, and would return 60 to 150 lbs of material from target asteroids. "Using resources harvested in space is the only way to afford permanent space development," said the company's chief executive David Gump. "More than 900 new asteroids that pass near Earth are discovered every year. They can be like the Iron Range of Minnesota was for the Detroit car industry last century - a key resource located near where it was needed. In this case, metals and fuel from asteroids can expand the in- space industries of this century." Asteroids could yield precious minerals such as gold, platinum and rare-Earth metals. But some are also thought to harbour water ice, which could be used as a raw material for the manufacture of rocket propellant or even breathable air. The other firm in the mining race, Planetary Resources, has backing from several billionaire investors, including Google's Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, software executive Charles Simonyi and filmmaker James Cameron. That company wants to start by launching orbiting telescopes that would identify suitable asteroid targets for mineral exploitation. However, some scientists struggle to see how cost-effective asteroid mining could be, even with the high value of gold and platinum. They point out that an upcoming Nasa mission to return just 60g (two ounces) of material from an asteroid will cost about $1bn. William Mook offered viable methods, but apparently it was far more important to trash outsiders like Mook and to otherwise discredit as many individuals as possible, so he moved himself back to New Zealand and seldom bothers to check back with any of these oligarch saturated Usenet/newsgroups. Mook can still be reached via email or through Linkedin: http://www.linkedin.com/ |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Mining comets/asteroids for water | Alain Fournier[_2_] | Technology | 8 | July 3rd 10 02:22 PM |
Which asteroids in our solar system would you use for mining??? | Sam Minewire | Astronomy Misc | 6 | April 2nd 09 02:58 AM |
CFP with extended deadline of Mar. 11, 2009: The 2009 InternationalConference on Data Mining (DMIN'09) & Sessions on Text/Web Mining, DataMining Applications, & Data Mining for Time Series, USA, July 13-16, 2009 | A. M. G. Solo | Astronomy Misc | 0 | March 4th 09 01:32 PM |
If You Want Ridiculous... | [email protected] | Amateur Astronomy | 2 | July 10th 05 10:24 PM |
Mining asteroids | Charles Immey | Amateur Astronomy | 6 | January 12th 04 07:22 PM |