|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension
Hi Maren -
This is a good question, for which there is no real answer. One can do these things, so the question becomes is it good practice? What should we recommend? One answer would be that if it is array data of any dimension it is reasonable to store it as an "image" (that is, a regularly sampled, multidimensional array, with associated metadata and possibly a WCS, flux units, etc.). This can include 1-D data such as a spectrum. If an IFU produces a spectral data cube then this qualifies as a 3-D image. If the IFU produces a bunch of 1-D spectra however, this is probably best stored as a table of 1-D spectra, e.g., as in the Euro-3D format (which is based on binary table). One can do things like pack the extracted spectra into the rows of a 2-D image, but aside from being a trick this is problematic when it comes to things such as associated error information or quality flags. I think these cases are all different than for example, storing a general file blob such as a GZIP as a 1-D byte "image". For that we want a general container which can say something about the contents, rather than pretend it is an Image object just because we can store it in an array. I would rather add a general container extension for this purpose. - Doug On Thu, 16 Aug 2007, Maren Purves wrote: Doug, Doug Tody wrote: My personal view on the more general question is that Image should only be used for image data, and it is a trick to stuff arbitrary binary blobs in something called an Image. But every multi-object spectrograph and every IFU does that on-chip already. And consider raster-scanning in radio/submm. Where do you want to draw the line? Aloha, Maren _______________________________________________ fitsbits mailing list http://listmgr.cv.nrao.edu/mailman/listinfo/fitsbits |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension | William Pence | FITS | 1 | August 17th 07 10:15 AM |
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension | Maren Purves | FITS | 0 | August 16th 07 10:54 PM |
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension | Steve Allen | FITS | 0 | August 16th 07 09:13 PM |
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension | William Pence | FITS | 0 | August 16th 07 08:51 PM |
[fitsbits] New DUMP FITS extension | Doug Tody | FITS | 0 | August 16th 07 08:23 PM |