#1
|
|||
|
|||
puzzle; Benzene
Dear john:
On Jun 2, 7:41*pm, john wrote: On Jun 2, 11:19*am, dlzc wrote: Dear Michael Moroney: On Jun 2, 9:50*am, (Michael Moroney) wrote: ...and your evidence that all those spinny coins have anything whatsoever to do with a real benzene molecule is what? That is the moeny he spent buying it? I am waiting for physics and chemistry based on Minecraft simulations to show up... Each member interacts with its neighbour four times per cycle. You can see that plainly since I had the 1, 4, 7 and 10 change color when they line up between two of the Carbon discs. During one cycle, with a ring of six, there will be 24 possible interactions. There is a neighbouring hydrogen for each member, also, but hydrogen is only capable of interacting twice per cycle, so for 6 hydrogens, that's another 12 interactions. That makes 36. This structure would accommodate Benzene's thirty sharing electrons admirably, don't you think, Holmes? No I think it is a masturbatory exercise, with no revelatory content, and no insight into helping someone understand the theories behind your intentional obfuscation. By the way, does your "model" explain why what is replaced for one or more hydrogens on benzine, controls what can be placed on next, and where? As long as you had a good time. David A. Smith |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
puzzle; Benzene
On Jun 3, 8:20*am, dlzc wrote:
Dear john: On Jun 2, 7:41*pm, john wrote: On Jun 2, 11:19*am, dlzc wrote: Dear Michael Moroney: On Jun 2, 9:50*am, (Michael Moroney) wrote: ...and your evidence that all those spinny coins have anything whatsoever to do with a real benzene molecule is what? That is the moeny he spent buying it? I am waiting for physics and chemistry based on Minecraft simulations to show up... Each member interacts with its neighbour four times per cycle. You can see that plainly since I had the 1, 4, 7 and 10 change color when they line up between two of the Carbon discs. During one cycle, with a ring of six, there will be 24 possible interactions. There is a neighbouring hydrogen for each member, also, but hydrogen is only capable of interacting twice per cycle, so for 6 hydrogens, that's another 12 interactions. That makes 36. This structure would accommodate Benzene's thirty sharing electrons admirably, don't you think, Holmes? No I think it is a masturbatory exercise, with no revelatory content, and no insight into helping someone understand the theories behind your intentional obfuscation. By the way, does your "model" explain why what is replaced for one or more hydrogens on benzine, controls what can be placed on next, and where? As long as you had a good time. Using the atomic model I've been championing for 28 years to demonstrate a classical pathway solution for Benzene? Yeah- a minor buzz. I'm bored now. john |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Logic Puzzle | [email protected] | Astronomy Misc | 2 | July 21st 07 07:24 AM |
Red Square puzzle. | Helios | UK Astronomy | 1 | April 21st 07 08:50 AM |
Eclipse puzzle | The Silver Fox | Amateur Astronomy | 13 | December 5th 04 06:26 AM |
Perihelion Puzzle | OG | UK Astronomy | 3 | January 6th 04 01:17 AM |
Puzzle for Michael | Dan Bloomquist | Astronomy Misc | 3 | October 28th 03 04:26 PM |