|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Red or green laser?
Question on which laser to buy. I've seen red lasers used to check on the surface of a mirror that was being ground. If I'm correct it was to see if the beam would reflect back, rather than penetrate, indicating more work needed to be done. But I see that green lasers are
used when pointing out objects in the night sky. My guess is, a 5mw or less power red laser would serve just fine when it comes to working on a mirror. Is this enough for pointing out object in the sky? Or does one need a green laser to do this? I realize atmospheric conditions will affect how well a laser works outside but under normal conditions is more than 5mw needed here? I've checked out some web sites posted on this NG which sell lasers. But many that I've checked are selling high priced items. If a $50 green laser does the job, why spend $200? True higher power may come into play but it seems some sites are simply counting on curiosity caused by newspaper articles to sell overpriced lasers. All I need is a simple, laser for the night sky with a dead man's switch to prevent accidnets from happening, any suggestions? I can buy a red laser anywhere it seems for as little as $9.99 to about $59 at some stores including radio shack. Again, 5mw on a red laser seems adequate for mirror grinding, why waste money but for night sky use is a green laser required? Thanks in advance for the help! |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
The red beam isn't visible to the eye. But a green beam is. I have=20
a $59 green laser from z-bolt.com and it works very well for pointing=20 out objects to a small group of people. -Florian |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
wrote: Question on which laser to buy. I've seen red lasers used to check on the surface of a mirror that was being ground. If I'm correct it was to see if the beam would reflect back, rather than penetrate, indicating more work needed to be done. But I see that green lasers are used when pointing out objects in the night sky. My guess is, a 5mw or less power red laser would serve just fine when it comes to working on a mirror. Is this enough for pointing out object in the sky? Or does one need a green laser to do this? I realize atmospheric conditions will affect how well a laser works outside but under normal conditions is more than 5mw needed here? I've checked out some web sites posted on this NG which sell lasers. But many that I've checked are selling high priced items. If a $50 green laser does the job, why spend $200? True higher power may come into play but it seems some sites are simply counting on curiosity caused by newspaper articles to sell overpriced lasers. All I need is a simple, laser for the night sky with a dead man's switch to prevent accidnets from happening, any suggestions? I can buy a red laser anywhere it seems for as little as $9.99 to about $59 at some stores including radio shack. Again, 5mw on a red laser seems adequate for mirror grinding, why waste money but for night sky use is a green laser required? Thanks in advance for the help! the reason you can see a green laser at night is because your eyes are more sensitive to it. you wont be able to see a red laser at night. how bright the green laser needs to be is dependant on how dark it is in your area. Ian Anderson www.customopticalsystems.com |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
baloney! I and many others have been using red lasers at night for years _
and the public sure sees them point at celestial objects _ Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say the red lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. you wont be able to see a red laser at night. how bright the green laser needs to be is dependant on how dark it is in your area. Ian Anderson www.customopticalsystems.com |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 20 Jan 2005 01:04:51 -0600, Warm Nights wrote:
baloney! I and many others have been using red lasers at night for years _ and the public sure sees them point at celestial objects _ Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say the red lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. I feel sorry for you, living under such miserable atmospheric conditions that a 5mW red laser makes an effective pointer to celestial objects! But for anyone living where the air is fairly clean, you really do need a green source if you hope for people to see much. If it is very clean and dry (as where I live) even the green laser is hard to see for anyone more than a few feet from the source. _________________________________________________ Chris L Peterson Cloudbait Observatory http://www.cloudbait.com |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see.=20
But to say the red lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. Must depend on the brightness of the particular red laser. I have a cheap red one and i can't see the beam. But with my also cheap green laser the beam is bright and easy to see. -Florian |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
I live where I live. We can;'t all be deities! (and blind to boot).
Chris L Peterson wrote: On Thu, 20 Jan 2005 01:04:51 -0600, Warm Nights wrote: baloney! I and many others have been using red lasers at night for years _ and the public sure sees them point at celestial objects _ Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say the red lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. I feel sorry for you, living under such miserable atmospheric conditions that a 5mW red laser makes an effective pointer to celestial objects! But for anyone living where the air is fairly clean, you really do need a green source if you hope for people to see much. If it is very clean and dry (as where I live) even the green laser is hard to see for anyone more than a few feet from the source. _________________________________________________ Chris L Peterson Cloudbait Observatory http://www.cloudbait.com |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
I suppose in the next breath you are going to say: "Im quitting amateur
astronomy. Cant have my green phaser! Next theywill take away my telescope and then my socks!". Florian wrote: Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say the red lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. Must depend on the brightness of the particular red laser. I have a cheap red one and i can't see the beam. But with my also cheap green laser the beam is bright and easy to see. -Florian |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
CL From: Chris L Peterson
CL Subject: Red or green laser? CL Date: Thu, 20 Jan 2005 15:10:34 GMT CL CL baloney! I and many others have been using red lasers at night for years _ CL and the public sure sees them point at celestial objects _ CL CL Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say CL the red CL lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. CL CL I feel sorry for you, living under such miserable atmospheric conditions that a CL 5mW red laser makes an effective pointer to celestial objects! But for anyone CL living where the air is fairly clean, you really do need a green source if you CL hope for people to see much. If it is very clean and dry (as where I live) even CL the green laser is hard to see for anyone more than a few feet from the source. In the age before laser pointers I and other astronomers worked star viewings at Jones Beach, Long Island. There we pointed out the stars with an automobile headlight! The lamp was loose to hol din the hands ans aim at the sky. That beam was so, erm, brilliant! In fact, for any fainter star, we had to aim off of it, wlse the star would be seamped. Or we drew a circle around it and told the visitors to look at the center of the circle. Jones Beach is on the south shore of Long Island, right smack in the airlane of Kennedy airport to the west. Planes regularly flew over or along the shore all night long. You may recall that the Air France flight that somehow exploded off of the Moriches, flew tight next to Jones Beach. --- þ RoseReader 2.52á P005004 ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==---- http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 100,000 Newsgroups ---= East/West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =--- |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Be careful not to point your spotlights skyward or the government may
spotlights and automobile headlights. "JOHN PAZMINO" wrote in message ... CL From: Chris L Peterson CL Subject: Red or green laser? CL Date: Thu, 20 Jan 2005 15:10:34 GMT CL CL baloney! I and many others have been using red lasers at night for years _ CL and the public sure sees them point at celestial objects _ CL CL Yes the green is easier to see - significantly easier to see. But to say CL the red CL lasers cant be seen is total nonsense. CL CL I feel sorry for you, living under such miserable atmospheric conditions that a CL 5mW red laser makes an effective pointer to celestial objects! But for anyone CL living where the air is fairly clean, you really do need a green source if you CL hope for people to see much. If it is very clean and dry (as where I live) even CL the green laser is hard to see for anyone more than a few feet from the source. In the age before laser pointers I and other astronomers worked star viewings at Jones Beach, Long Island. There we pointed out the stars with an automobile headlight! The lamp was loose to hol din the hands ans aim at the sky. That beam was so, erm, brilliant! In fact, for any fainter star, we had to aim off of it, wlse the star would be seamped. Or we drew a circle around it and told the visitors to look at the center of the circle. Jones Beach is on the south shore of Long Island, right smack in the airlane of Kennedy airport to the west. Planes regularly flew over or along the shore all night long. You may recall that the Air France flight that somehow exploded off of the Moriches, flew tight next to Jones Beach. --- þ RoseReader 2.52á P005004 ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==---- http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 100,000 Newsgroups ---= East/West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =--- |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Flash Blinded By Green Laser | Gary Honis | Amateur Astronomy | 136 | January 29th 05 04:09 AM |
More on Green Laser Concerns.... | Ted Nichols II | Amateur Astronomy | 8 | January 5th 05 06:06 PM |
A Taxonomy of Auroras | Canopus | Amateur Astronomy | 0 | November 12th 04 08:03 AM |
Our future as a species - Fermi Paradox revisted - Where they all are | william mook | Policy | 157 | November 19th 03 12:19 AM |
Green Hills Helps JPL go to Mars | Ron Baalke | Astronomy Misc | 0 | August 11th 03 05:05 PM |