#1
|
|||
|
|||
making hot rocks
There has been talk about possible danger from Asteroid Apophis in 2036
after being deflected when passes us in 2029. I have seen discussion of using an impacter like that NASA recently used on the comet and seen discussion of "painting" an asteroid to deflect it. However, if the asteroid is just a pile of rubble, how do you "paint" its surface. Its surface is very likely to change with time. If you are worried about the structural integrity of the asteroid, an impact is the worst thing you could do. This puts us back to the old idea of using nukes but it is not as depicted in the silly "Armegeddon" movie where they drill into the asteroid. Instead, you explode the nuke some distance from the surface and allow the intense burst of low energy x-rays to cause "blow-off" from the surface. Considering that we have a lot of control over the x-ray spectrum and even maybe the x-ray emission time, nukes offer the widest range of "push" options. I think (back of the envelope sipping a cup of coffee thinking) that a nuke exploded at sufficient distance so that the ratio of distance to asteroid rubble pile diameter was large, would actually tend to push the rubble together while giving it an impulse as a whole. Has there been a study of the various combos of nuke yield, x-ray spectrum, pulse time, distance etc to get various DeltaV for various types of asteroid? It would be fun to do and wouldn't cost anything if one could get access to the classified nuke data and access to some x-ray deposition impulse codes. Once that was known, it would be interesting to see what the various options would be for different orbital scenarios, such as the optimum place to do the detonation(s). I assume it might take several detonations of various kinds. Once that was done, start looking at existing hardware such as ICBM warhead busses to carry and dispense the nukes. What could be done to modify them. What could be done in a short term and what would need development. What launch vehicles could be used. Has any of this been done? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
making hot rocks
Frogwatch wrote:
Has there been a study of the various combos of nuke yield, x-ray spectrum, pulse time, distance etc to get various DeltaV for various types of asteroid? It would be fun to do and wouldn't cost anything if one could get access to the classified nuke data and access to some x-ray deposition impulse codes. Someone ran the numbers (on Usenet, but I don't have the reference to hand) for Apophis back when a 2029 impact was an open question, using public data. The answer was that a single medium-size bomb (that could be carried by existing launchers) detonated near the asteroid would impart enough impulse for a miss. This could be done with plenty of time to spare for followup shots in case the first one didn't do the job, and it could be kept below the asteroid's gravitational binding energy to make followup shots easier if needed. -- "Always look on the bright side of life." To reply by email, replace no.spam with my last name. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
curvature of old rocks | don findlay | Astronomy Misc | 4 | June 25th 06 04:22 AM |
Odd Rocks on Mars | [email protected] | Research | 0 | April 14th 06 10:25 AM |
Any rocks from Venus? | Orion | Research | 0 | May 14th 04 08:24 AM |
Opportunity Rocks! | Bill Ferris | Amateur Astronomy | 6 | January 25th 04 05:18 AM |
Martian Rocks | Andrew McKay | Misc | 15 | July 20th 03 07:59 PM |