|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D
But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? One tongue-in-cheek scenario I can think of. Georgia/South-Ossetia situation heats back up. USAF parks X37B close enough to ISS to block ability to take photos of the ground! :-) Dave |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On 09/11/2010 09:58 PM, David Spain wrote:
OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? Wrong inclination, highly doubtful X-37B has enough plane change capability. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On 12/09/2010 12:58 PM, David Spain wrote:
OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? One tongue-in-cheek scenario I can think of. Georgia/South-Ossetia situation heats back up. USAF parks X37B close enough to ISS to block ability to take photos of the ground! :-) It would have to be in a slightly lower orbit to have that effect. Keeping it on station would use its propellant up in short order I'd expect. Haven't done the sums though. Sylvia |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On 9/11/2010 6:58 PM, David Spain wrote:
OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? One tongue-in-cheek scenario I can think of. Georgia/South-Ossetia situation heats back up. USAF parks X37B close enough to ISS to block ability to take photos of the ground! :-) I don't think its orbital inclination allows that, even with its limited delta v ability to modify its orbit inclination and altitude. Pat |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
Jorge R. Frank wrote:
On 09/11/2010 09:58 PM, David Spain wrote: OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? Wrong inclination, highly doubtful X-37B has enough plane change capability. I was presuming on a reflight mission. -- Greg Moore Ask me about lily, an RPI based CMC. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On 09/12/2010 12:55 PM, David Spain wrote:
Greg D. Moore (Strider) wrote: Jorge R. Frank wrote: On 09/11/2010 09:58 PM, David Spain wrote: OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? Wrong inclination, highly doubtful X-37B has enough plane change capability. I was presuming on a reflight mission. Yes. Not the current one. Then the limiting factor is whether X-37B has relnav sensors and software. I don't believe the current one does. Don't know if they're developing such capability for a followon. Bottom line is, anything's possible if they put the development work (read: money) in. But isn't the reality more likely that this will be launched on very very high inclination orbits from Vandenberg? Seems likely to be the more useful orbits for its, ahem, intended purpose... And would these be too highly inclined for the ISS or about right? Too highly inclined. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On Sep 12, 11:43*am, "Jorge R. Frank" wrote:
On 09/12/2010 12:55 PM, David Spain wrote: Greg D. Moore (Strider) wrote: Jorge R. Frank wrote: On 09/11/2010 09:58 PM, David Spain wrote: OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? Wrong inclination, highly doubtful X-37B has enough plane change capability. I was presuming on a reflight mission. Yes. Not the current one. Then the limiting factor is whether X-37B has relnav sensors and software. I don't believe the current one does. Don't know if they're developing such capability for a followon. Bottom line is, anything's possible if they put the development work (read: money) in. But isn't the reality more likely that this will be launched on very very high inclination orbits from Vandenberg? Seems likely to be the more useful orbits for its, ahem, intended purpose... And would these be too highly inclined for the ISS or about right? Too highly inclined. Not only software, but it would need the radar and docking mechanisms in order to do it all Which begs the question, why bother doing it anyways. It seems to me it would open a huge political can of worms to have a military spacecraft dock with a civilian space station. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On Sep 12, 3:46*pm, M wrote:
On Sep 12, 11:43*am, "Jorge R. Frank" wrote: On 09/12/2010 12:55 PM, David Spain wrote: Greg D. Moore (Strider) wrote: Jorge R. Frank wrote: On 09/11/2010 09:58 PM, David Spain wrote: OK, gotcha, I made this up. :-D But seriously, can anyone think of a legit scenario where this could happen? Can the X37-B reach the ISS? Or are all its capabilities so deeply classified no-one can say? Wrong inclination, highly doubtful X-37B has enough plane change capability. I was presuming on a reflight mission. Yes. Not the current one. Then the limiting factor is whether X-37B has relnav sensors and software. I don't believe the current one does. Don't know if they're developing such capability for a followon. Bottom line is, anything's possible if they put the development work (read: money) in. But isn't the reality more likely that this will be launched on very very high inclination orbits from Vandenberg? Seems likely to be the more useful orbits for its, ahem, intended purpose... And would these be too highly inclined for the ISS or about right? Too highly inclined. Not only software, but it would need the radar and docking mechanisms in order to do it all Which begs the question, why bother doing it anyways. It seems to me it would open a huge political can of worms to have a military spacecraft dock with a civilian space station.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - well the shuttle originally did all military missions..... |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
X37B to rendezvous with ISS....
On 9/12/2010 9:55 AM, David Spain wrote:
I was presuming on a reflight mission. Yes. Not the current one. Considering how well the recent scramjet and hypersonic glide vehicle tests went, I wouldn't be to sure about a reflight till they get it successfully back. ;-) Although I doubt they would launch it into a similar orbit with the ISS, I could certainly see it using the ISS as a target for experimental optical and radar sensors in the cargo bay, as one of the missions a spacecraft like this could do is inspection of other satellites on-orbit, and having a object of known dimensions to check the sensor's resolution on would be a asset (when they launched the MOL mock-up into orbit on the Titan III, they had painted its exterior with various sized stripes so they could image it with ground-based cameras and see how good their resolution was.) Pat |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Rendezvous with Rama | Maurice W | UK Astronomy | 4 | March 18th 07 04:24 PM |
Rendezvous in space | Rich Godwin | Policy | 2 | January 6th 07 11:24 AM |
It's May 25: Just Another Day, or Rendezvous with Doom? | Double-A | Misc | 3 | May 25th 06 12:44 PM |
Rendezvous with Rama | Richard Cavell | Science | 2 | March 26th 04 11:39 PM |