|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Orbital compass
I noticed a scene last week on Enterprise where the captain gave a
gift ship's compass to the first officer. Question: given a non-ferrous place on the ISS, would a compass point toward the North Magnetic Pole? Has this experiment ever been tried on ISS, or are there just too many magnetic fields on-board? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
I guess compasses don't work on ships like those of star trek (not even the
most advanced technique will ever be able to get rid of every field). Compasses wouldn't work in general, but that all depends on where (and how) you are in space. "TVDad Jim" schreef in bericht om... I noticed a scene last week on Enterprise where the captain gave a gift ship's compass to the first officer. Question: given a non-ferrous place on the ISS, would a compass point toward the North Magnetic Pole? Has this experiment ever been tried on ISS, or are there just too many magnetic fields on-board? |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
TVDad Jim wrote:
Question: given a non-ferrous place on the ISS, would a compass point toward the North Magnetic Pole? No. A compass in general doesn't point toward the magnetic north pole, it aligns itself, so that it is parallel to the field lines of the local magnetic field.* Given a place in space with no disturbing magnetic fields in the vicinity, this should work in space. Has this experiment ever been tried on ISS, or are there just too many magnetic fields on-board? Hm, I doubt it. There wouldn't be much reason to do it. But a lot of satellites have mapped Earth's magnetic field from orbit, e.g. the very succesful Danish satellite, Oersted. /steen * Actually, a compass on Earth generally points toward the Earth's magnetic /south/ pole, which is located in northern Canada. That's why the north pole of a compass points north :-) |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Marco van Woerden" Compasses wouldn't work in general, because..... but that all depends on where (and how) you are in space. For example...... |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
TVDad Jim wrote:
I noticed a scene last week on Enterprise where the captain gave a gift ship's compass to the first officer. Question: given a non-ferrous place on the ISS, would a compass point toward the North Magnetic Pole? Has this experiment ever been tried on ISS, or are there just too many magnetic fields on-board? To be precise, an orbital magnet would indeed tend to align itself with the planetary field as it traveled along. It also, of course, responds similarly to *all* the various fields in which it's immersed. (May the locally strongest field win!) Magnetometers have been carried on satellites for many years to map the field, and they do it exactly in this way, but they're also placed on long, inert booms to get them far away from the rest of the spacecraft. If you get the instrument far enough away from all the other hardware, the various small magnetic fields become weak, and also can tend to cancel each other if the engineers have been clever enough to orient all the sources just so. This is true of the Pioneers 10 & 11 interplanetary probes, and their close relatives, the Voyagers 1 & 2. These spacecraft carry their magnetometers way out on the ends of long poles. But they also still have some small contamination by their own, small magnetic fields. So occasionally they'll do a calibration run, in which, as they slowly rotate, they map their own fields. This is then subtracted from the overall data on the ambient field in deep space. Less rigorously, astronauts have also played with small dimestore magnets while on orbit. If you impart a small rotation to the free falling magnet, given enough time it actually loses its rotational energy to Earth's field and settles into continuous alignment with the changing field. -Mark Martin |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
TVDad Jim wrote: Question: given a non-ferrous place on the ISS, would a compass point toward the North Magnetic Pole? Well, kind of -- it would do that if it were constrained to rotate only horizontally. As others have explained, a compass needle tries to line itself up with the local magnetic field, whose horizontal component points to the N.M.P. But the field is generally not horizontal; this matters even on aircraft, where you have to remember that if you're banking for a turn, the compass will be lying to you somewhat. Three-axis magnetometers -- which give a full 3D determination of the field direction -- are routinely used for attitude sensing on LEO spacecraft, and given a few orbits worth of data and a good magnetic-field model, they can also be used for orbit determination. Has this experiment ever been tried on ISS, or are there just too many magnetic fields on-board? I would guess that ISS is too magnetically "dirty" for a compass to work very well, unless perhaps you found just the right place for it. Building magnetically-clean spacecraft is somewhat of an art, and it imposes some significant constraints, so it's not done unless there is real need. (Even MOST puts its magnetometers out on short booms to get them away from the rest of the spacecraft -- not the electronics, interestingly enough, but the Invar components in the athermal telescope structure.) -- "Think outside the box -- the box isn't our friend." | Henry Spencer -- George Herbert | |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Steen wrote: * Actually, a compass on Earth generally points toward the Earth's magnetic /south/ pole, which is located in northern Canada. That's why the north pole of a compass points north :-) Yes and no and kind of. There are two separate uses of "north" and "south" here, and it's important not to confuse them. What's normally spoken of as the North Magnetic Pole is the magnetic pole that is in the Northern Hemisphere. Confusingly, this is a *south* pole by the polarity standard normally used for magnets, but that doesn't mean that it's referred to as such when discussing geography. A further complication is that because Earth's magnetic center is not at its geometric center, the places where a three-axis magnetometer reports that the field is vertical -- which are the places usually reported as the magnetic poles -- are *not* in fact the places where the axis of Earth's magnetic dipole intersects the surface. To say nothing of the fact that the field is not an exact dipole... and is changing with time in poorly-understood ways. -- "Think outside the box -- the box isn't our friend." | Henry Spencer -- George Herbert | |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Henry Spencer wrote: Well, kind of -- it would do that if it were constrained to rotate only horizontally. As others have explained, a compass needle tries to line itself up with the local magnetic field, whose horizontal component points to the N.M.P. But the field is generally not horizontal; this matters even on aircraft, where you have to remember that if you're banking for a turn, the compass will be lying to you somewhat. Three-axis magnetometers -- which give a full 3D determination of the field direction -- are routinely used for attitude sensing on LEO spacecraft, and given a few orbits worth of data and a good magnetic-field model, they can also be used for orbit determination. Geologists also use a multiaxis, or "dip" compass to determine the local magnetic fields of rock strata. Pat |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Henry Spencer wrote:
Yes and no and kind of. There are two separate uses of "north" and "south" here, and it's important not to confuse them. What's normally spoken of as the North Magnetic Pole is the magnetic pole that is in the Northern Hemisphere. Confusingly, this is a *south* pole by the polarity standard normally used for magnets, but that doesn't mean that it's referred to as such when discussing geography. I stand corrected. /steen |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Space Calendar - January 28, 2005 | [email protected] | Astronomy Misc | 1 | January 31st 05 09:33 AM |
Space Calendar - December 23, 2004 | [email protected] | Misc | 0 | December 23rd 04 04:03 PM |
Space Calendar - December 23, 2004 | [email protected] | Astronomy Misc | 0 | December 23rd 04 04:03 PM |
Space Calendar - October 28, 2004 | Ron | History | 0 | October 28th 04 03:41 PM |
Hans Moravec's Original Rotovator Paper | James Bowery | Policy | 0 | July 6th 04 07:45 AM |