|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
[fitsbits] SDFITS Convention Comment: Hardware Keywords
Greetings. On 2010 Aug 17, at 20:32, Eric Greisen wrote: Tom Kuiper wrote: The TELESCOP keyword is required in the extension header and its associated value will be a unique string which identifies the antenna or antenna array and can be used as a key to a database of antenna parameters. NRAO will maintain a registry for TELESCOP keyword values. I actually like the idea of a registry - but who at NRAO did you have in mind? There was once a FITS office informally at NRAO but that individual retired some years ago. The AIPS project has been deprecated for many years and depends solely on me to keep all its users afloat. The CASA project has little to no interest in FITS. The VLB users maintain a registry of sorts but at a more detailed level intended to represent that multiple names and abbreviations used for the same telescopes when they are used in various VLBI configurations. An alternative to a registry (or, in one view, a decentralised zeroconf registry) is to require that the TELESCOP value be a URI. This URI should be one which the telescope, or its associated archive, publishes as the long-term 'name' of the instrument. When retrieved, it can return either or both of human-readable and machine-readable information about the instrument and its parameters. There are Standards-based ways of doing this. Having said that, a URI can function perfectly happily as a _name_ for a thing, without it being required to be dereferenceable. The DNS provides the namespacing and uniqueness guarantees. If it's desirable (and I think it is) to have a half-way house between this decentralised approach and something more registry-like, then there'd be a very good case for using PURLs (see http://purl.org) to add a level of (curatable) indirection. This would also help to keep the URIs within the FITS value character limit. Best wishes, Norman -- Norman Gray : http://nxg.me.uk School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Glasgow, UK |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
[fitsbits] SDFITS Convention Comment: Hardware Keywords | Eric Greisen | FITS | 0 | August 17th 10 08:32 PM |