|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
A month long solar conjunction downtime is about to effect
Curosity...... It will be out of communication for about a month, given its flakey computer we will be lucky if communications are restored after the conjunction. that brings about the question.... how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering communications can continue? other than cost are there any other issues preventing this? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
: bob haller
: how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering : communications can continue? What's a "heliospheric orbit"? You just made that up, didn't you? And have no idea what you really mean by it, right? |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
:: how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering
:: communications can continue? :: other than cost are there any other issues preventing this? : Fred J. McCall : there are no overriding technical reasons why it couldn't be done. : You'd need a new rocket, Which would double the price of the mission. I had heard bob was for less expensive missions? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
:: how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering
:: communications can continue? :: other than cost are there any other issues preventing this? : Fred J. McCall : there are no overriding technical reasons why it couldn't be done. : You'd need a new rocket, Which would double the price of the mission. I had heard bob was for less expensive missions? Well you wouldn't fly one per mission. You'd use it for multiple missions. My question is would a satellite at an Earth-Sun Trojan point have enough angle to see Mars during conjunction or would you still have the same issues? -- Greg D. Moore http://greenmountainsoftware.wordpress.com/ CEO QuiCR: Quick, Crowdsourced Responses. http://www.quicr.net |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
On Mar 20, 3:00*pm, "Greg \(Strider\) Moore"
wrote: :: how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering :: communications can continue? :: other than cost are there any other issues preventing this? : Fred J. McCall : there are no overriding technical reasons why it couldn't be done. : You'd need a new rocket, Which would double the price of the mission. I had heard bob was for less expensive missions? Well you wouldn't fly one per mission. *You'd use it for multiple missions. My question is would a satellite at an Earth-Sun Trojan point have enough angle to see Mars during conjunction or would you still have the same issues? -- Greg D. Moore * * * * * * * * *http://greenmountainsoftware.wordpress.com/ CEO QuiCR: Quick, Crowdsourced Responses.http://www.quicr.net it might be interesting to send a unmanned mission to retrieve some of the stuff at the trogan points. theres other stuff in heliospheric, snoopy some saturn 2nd stages and other leftovers of the space age.... the communication craft could be placed in a permanent orbit to be used as a relay satellite for communications. lets not forget the vehicles that were lost, and no clear reason due to lack of communications.... this sort of vehicle could not only be used as a communications relay but also have uses looking for comets and meteors that could be a hazard some day...... give it large solar panels for a long life expectancy, a backup RTG that would also keep it somewhat warm, while supplying some power, and a ion engine for station keeping and long term testing. it would be awesome if it could during its mission take pictures of other things in heliospheric orbit like snoopy. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
Fred J. McCall writes:
(Wayne Throop) wrote: :: how about a relay sat in heliospheric orbit so at least engineering :: communications can continue? :: other than cost are there any other issues preventing this? : Fred J. McCall : there are no overriding technical reasons why it couldn't be done. : You'd need a new rocket, Which would double the price of the mission. I had heard bob was for less expensive missions? Only when he wants to be. He said "other than cost". Yeah, so what's wrong with wanting to discuss that idea? It's not that anyone here will have to decide if something like this will be launched anyway. Jochem -- "A designer knows he has arrived at perfection not when there is no longer anything to add, but when there is no longer anything to take away." - Antoine de Saint-Exupery |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
I think it's pretty clear that he means a relay in an orbit around the sun that would allow continious communications between Earth and Mars.. Which probably isn't worth the money, especially for aging flaky rovers. If something's suspect of not surviving a month of not being closely monitored it's probably hardly worth saving anymore. * * * * Jochem Well curosity is brand new as rovers go, but a relay sat could not only relay from mars but other planets. if opportunity goes dead no one will know what went wrong Having at least a engineering data link could be useful when vehicles are lost. Could be used for searching for comets and meteors, might be able to image lost vehicles like snoopy in heliospheric orbit somewhere, and might even be useful as a relay for moon operations away from earth |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
:: What's a "heliospheric orbit"?
:: You just made that up, didn't you? :: And have no idea what you really mean by it, right? I googled it also, fwiw. It's used in a few places, but incoherently. Possibly Bob picked it up from some other orbital-mechanics-challenged individual. : Jochem Huhmann : I think it's pretty clear that he means a relay in an orbit around the : sun that would allow continious communications between Earth and Mars. In which case, I conclude you need an orbit in either an earth-sun L[45] point, or an earth-mars L[45] point. Otherwise, it's difficult to ensure that you can always send a message without expensive fuel use. Or, naict. : Which probably isn't worth the money, especially for aging flaky : rovers. If something's suspect of not surviving a month of not being : closely monitored it's probably hardly worth saving anymore. Yes, if that's the only application. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Mars solar conjunction downtime
On Mar 22, 12:08*am, (Wayne Throop) wrote:
:: What's a "heliospheric orbit"? :: You just made that up, didn't you? :: And have no idea what you really mean by it, right? I googled it also, fwiw. *It's used in a few places, but incoherently. Possibly Bob picked it up from some other orbital-mechanics-challenged individual. : Jochem Huhmann : I think it's pretty clear that he means a relay in an orbit around the : sun that would allow continious communications between Earth and Mars. In which case, I conclude you need an orbit in either an earth-sun L[45] point, or an earth-mars L[45] point. *Otherwise, it's difficult to ensure that you can always send a message without expensive fuel use. *Or, naict. : Which probably isn't worth the money, especially for aging flaky : rovers. *If something's suspect of not surviving a month of not being : closely monitored it's probably hardly worth saving anymore. Yes, if that's the only application. think of the mars probes lost when out of contract with earth, they just go silent forever... a couple robust comm sats in order could at minimum supply info when such losses occur, hopefuly prerventing a reoccurence at a later date, while being useful other activities |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
How close is the current Mars/moon conjunction? | Bland | Astronomy Misc | 2 | February 2nd 10 01:11 AM |
Astro: Mercury, Jupiter, Mars Conjunction Series | Edward Erbeck | Astro Pictures | 5 | December 16th 06 10:14 PM |
S@H downtime | Victor | SETI | 2 | March 3rd 05 05:28 PM |
Mesa in the background of Mars landing site coal found on Mars; CellWell1 and CellWell2 origins of the Solar System | Archimedes Plutonium | Astronomy Misc | 14 | January 10th 04 03:13 AM |