![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Not much work seems to be done nowadays on open (aka hyperbolic) or
closed (aka spherical) manifolds, but it's instructive to consider what they would look like as a nightsky. The answer is they would look just the same as flat space, but if one were to hop in a rocket and travel out there, one would find that objects are closer than their angular size indicates in an open manifold (i.e., "foreshortened"), and in a closed manifold they would be further away than expected. So nowadays we model that we can't visually distinguish at all between these alternative curvatures. But spectroscopy illustrates how nature finds ways to convey information -- astronomers of 100 years ago would be astonished at how much signal there is in mere light. My supposition is that there is indeed a visual way to distinguish between open, flat, and closed manifolds, and that the cosmological redshift shows us the way. Regardless of all the complex constructs of standard cosmology, the simple anchor is that cosmological redshift results from recession. No recession, no big bang. So alternative viewpoints of the redshift are not welcome to some -- which is no reason not to try, of course. Lopez-Corredoira gave a useful review of static models in his paper "Angular Size Test on the Expansion of the Universe" (2010 IJMP,19,245; arxiv:1002.0525) and observed (as have others) that 1/z is well-fit to angular size across all redshifts -- without need of evolution, dark matter, dark energy, whatever. Occam is calling. So these are threads for me to follow, hopefully to assemble into a coherent whole, after the holidays. cheers, Eric. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Riemannian geometry etc. | Koobee Wublee | Astronomy Misc | 1 | April 11th 11 11:16 AM |
Geometry | Brian Gaff | Space Shuttle | 2 | October 27th 07 07:12 AM |
Dome Geometry? | Davoud | Amateur Astronomy | 7 | December 26th 05 07:21 PM |
Geometry in the sky | Johan | Astronomy Misc | 14 | September 30th 04 09:28 AM |
Geometry and Leveling... -- Thanks! | Davoud | Amateur Astronomy | 0 | April 11th 04 10:51 PM |