How the gas Giants planets gathered their gas at formation

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

Mitch Raemsch

"BURT" wrote in message
...
I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.



No, but starstuffs do.

On Sep 27, 6:30*pm, "Mark Earnest" wrote:
"BURT" wrote in message

...

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

No, but starstuffs do.

Those starstuffs I take to be the heavier elements that would make the
gas giants core capturing the gas.

Mitch Raemsch

"BURT" wrote in message
...
On Sep 27, 6:30 pm, "Mark Earnest" wrote:
"BURT" wrote in message

...

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

No, but starstuffs do.

Those starstuffs I take to be the heavier elements that would make the
gas giants core capturing the gas.

***Sure, you could put it like that. But they would have to be pretty
amazingly heavy if scattered molecules of themselves are going to
somehow float together through space.

BURT wrote:
I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

Next time you make a fire, set a stone in it for an hour, or so.

When the flames die-down, place a leaf on the stone.

Imagine the stone being as large as The Moon, its gravity hugging all the
byproducts of that thermal transfer...
--
ah

Too bad for your theory, Mitch, that all that GAS wasn't separated out
BEFORE the metals formed up! lmao! Science isn't always so clean.

MILLIONS of TONS of GAS sure do add up gravitywise!

It all starts with TWO atoms or molecules sticking together. (We've
been over this before!)

Saul Levy


On Sat, 27 Sep 2008 19:15:30 -0700 (PDT), BURT
wrote:

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

Mitch Raemsch

Most "starstuff" is light elements, Mitch. You know: hydrogen,
helium, etc.

Anything above helium is considered a METAL by astrophysicists.
(We've covered that topic before too!)

Saul Levy


On Sat, 27 Sep 2008 21:10:27 -0700 (PDT), BURT
wrote:

On Sep 27, 6:30*pm, "Mark Earnest" wrote:
"BURT" wrote in message

...

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

No, but starstuffs do.

Those starstuffs I take to be the heavier elements that would make the
gas giants core capturing the gas.

Mitch Raemsch

And you're an EXPERT now on scattered stuff, Mark?

This from a MAN (?) who rejects EVERYTHING that SCIENCE has
determined, but believes in ANGELS?

BAWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

We've read your STUFF before, Mark. It's all A BIG JOKE!

Not much left for us to go on! I don't mean toilets!

Saul Levy


On Sat, 27 Sep 2008 23:54:53 -0500, "Mark Earnest"
wrote:


"BURT" wrote in message
...
On Sep 27, 6:30 pm, "Mark Earnest" wrote:
"BURT" wrote in message

...

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

No, but starstuffs do.

Those starstuffs I take to be the heavier elements that would make the
gas giants core capturing the gas.

***Sure, you could put it like that. But they would have to be pretty
amazingly heavy if scattered molecules of themselves are going to
somehow float together through space.

Cactus saul Best you realize Jupiter core mass is 15 times greater than
the whole earth. Even you being a no brainer that has to tell you some
thing(I hope) bert

"Saul Levy" wrote in message
...
And you're an EXPERT now on scattered stuff, Mark?

This from a MAN (?) who rejects EVERYTHING that SCIENCE has
determined, but believes in ANGELS?

BAWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

We've read your STUFF before, Mark. It's all A BIG JOKE!

Not much left for us to go on! I don't mean toilets!

Saul Levy


This from a man that believes SCIENTISTS?
Those idiots that can't get us out of Earth orbit 39 years after landing
a man on the Moon?

Over the cliff you go, lemming!






On Sat, 27 Sep 2008 23:54:53 -0500, "Mark Earnest"
wrote:


"BURT" wrote in message
...
On Sep 27, 6:30 pm, "Mark Earnest" wrote:
"BURT" wrote in message

...

I believe they started as a huge rock metal core greater than the
mass
of the earth that was capable of gathering their huge gas atmospheres
through great gravity. Gas by itself does not possess enough gravity.

No, but starstuffs do.

Those starstuffs I take to be the heavier elements that would make the
gas giants core capturing the gas.

***Sure, you could put it like that. But they would have to be pretty
amazingly heavy if scattered molecules of themselves are going to
somehow float together through space.