The Pledge

I've been asked by some SAA members reinstate "The Pledge"
Some may remember from years gone bye "The Pledge" which helped remove
Trolls from SAA.
So sign up today and let's get back to what we're here for :-)

Goto
http://web.mac.com/gaslee/iWeb/Site/The%20Pledge.html
and then Email me "The Pledge" along with your name and I'll add you to
the list.

Clear skies
--
Gareth

Random Thoughts and Interests
http://web.mac.com/gaslee/iWeb/Site/Blog/Blog.html

Gareth Slee wrote:
I've been asked by some SAA members reinstate "The Pledge"
Some may remember from years gone bye "The Pledge" which helped remove
Trolls from SAA.
So sign up today and let's get back to what we're here for :-)

Goto
http://web.mac.com/gaslee/iWeb/Site/The%20Pledge.html
and then Email me "The Pledge" along with your name and I'll add you to
the list.

Alright. I'll give it The Senator's Try. No wait, I mean I promise not
to feed the trolls. :-)
Does Rich count? He's not always a troll.

Shawn

"Shawn" sdotherecurry@bresnannextdotnet wrote in message
. ..
Gareth Slee wrote:
I've been asked by some SAA members reinstate "The Pledge"
Some may remember from years gone bye "The Pledge" which helped remove
Trolls from SAA.
So sign up today and let's get back to what we're here for :-)

Goto
http://web.mac.com/gaslee/iWeb/Site/The%20Pledge.html
and then Email me "The Pledge" along with your name and I'll add you to
the list.

Alright. I'll give it The Senator's Try. No wait, I mean I promise not
to feed the trolls. :-)
Does Rich count? He's not always a troll.

Shawn

That's a tough call, but you've called it right. Rich is not ALWAYS a
troll. And lately, he's been a little more on -topic than he often has in
the recent past.

He's spent a lot of time in my killfile, but he's also a well-seasoned
amateur astronomer, who has a LOT of experience he can share, when he's in
the mood to do so.

I always TRY to give Rich a little space, because I KNOW what he CAN do as a
contributor here. But that has often been tempered by the negative side of
his *other* posts...

The problem often has been what he IS doing at any given moment. Right now,
his pluses exceed his minuses. Who KNOWS what tomorrow may bring.

--
Jan Owen

To reach me directly, remove the Z, if one appears in my e-mail address...
Latitude: 33.6
Longitude: -112.3

Gareth Slee wrote:
I've been asked by some SAA members reinstate "The Pledge"
Some may remember from years gone bye "The Pledge" which helped remove
Trolls from SAA.
So sign up today and let's get back to what we're here for :-)

Goto
http://web.mac.com/gaslee/iWeb/Site/The%20Pledge.html
and then Email me "The Pledge" along with your name and I'll add you to
the list.



Hi Gareth:

Thanks for bringing this back, bro.

Peace,
Rod Mollise
Author of _Choosing and Using a Schmidt Cassegrain Telescope_
and _The Urban Astronomer's Guide_

Like SCTs and MCTs?
Join the SCT User Mailing List.
http://www.groups.yahoo.com/group/sct-user

See my home page at
http://skywatch.brainiac.com/astroland/index.htm
for further info

For Uncle Rod's Astro Blog See:
http://journals.aol.com/rmollise/UncleRodsAstroBlog/

You've got to be kidding. That didn't remove any trolls from the
system. On the other hand, Del "Laserpointer" Johnson is gone. Maybe
you've got something there.


Gareth Slee wrote:
I've been asked by some SAA members reinstate "The Pledge"
Some may remember from years gone bye "The Pledge" which helped remove
Trolls from SAA.

If you were real astronomers you would have little time for group hugs
and pledges.

The pledge of an observational astronomer is to correctly plot the
positions of planets using the stellar background as a reference but
not to include the stellar background when drawing conclusions -

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ima...loop_tezel.jpg

The pledge of a real heliocentric astronomer is to actively present the
actual motions of the forward moving Jupiter overtaking the slower
forward moving Saturn -

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ima...loop_tezel.jpg

To account for the other feature is to present the faster moving Earth
overtaking both those outer planets.Then and only then can you ever
dare to breathe the words 'astronomer and astronomy'.

You can remain 2 dimensional quasi- geocentrists if you adhere to this
putrid mutation of the Copernican insight -

"For to the earth planetary motions appear sometimes direct, sometimes
stationary, nay, and sometimes retrograde. But from the sun they are
always seen direct,"

NEWTON


So,pledge to your heart's content but you are no astronomers until that
awful 17th century misjudgement/misconduct is corrected.

Correction

The forward orbital motion of the Earth resolves the appearance and
slower forward motion of Jupiter and the even slower forward moving
Saturn -


http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ima...2000_tezel.gif

If none of you can recognise that then forget about pledges for
otherwise you will remain Newtonian quasi-geocentrists locked within
your 2 dimensional celestial sphere bubble.

I take no satisfaction from all this,promoting the actual reasoning of
Copernicus and Kepler was my business and whatever insults that rain
down in this direction,nothing can take away the disappointment of
watching the great astronomical insights and methods of Copernicus and
Kepler brought down to the dismal condition it exists in today.

I have promoted the Copernican insight and recognise that it truly
blossoms using time lapse footage of actual planetary motion, a feature
that Copernicus,Kepler and Galileo had to imagine intutively so there
is no excuse for getting it wrong as Newton did.Kepler was well aware
that Copernican heliocentricity was open to mutations such as the
Tychonian view* but there were not enough competent astronomers around
to grasp the Newtonian mutation.

You see me as an enemy ,a troll or some other buzzword but I see only
intellectual and intutive laziness.


* "And though some disparate astronomical hypotheses may provide
exactly
the same results in astronomy, as Rothmann claimed in his letters to
Lord Tycho of his own mutation of the Copernican system,nevertheless
there is often a difference between the conclusions because of some
physical consideration [causa alicujus considerationis physicae]....
But practitioners are not always in the habit of taking account of that

diversity in physical matters [in physicisvarietas], . . " KEPLER

Coppy was saying
You've got to be kidding. That didn't
remove any trolls from the system.

It didn't REMOVE the trolls, but it shortened their threads
considerably, and the signal to noise ratio got better. A few might
just go away if ignored.
Marty

Marty wrote:

It didn't REMOVE the trolls, but it shortened their threads
considerably, and the signal to noise ratio got better. A few might
just go away if ignored.

I don't know what planet you came from, but this group has more trolls
on it today than ever before. Check out oriel's response on this
thread. It has never been as bad. And the local yocals still respond to
the trolls, over and over again. Did you see Davoud's troll bait on
Windows vs. Mac? The people who have left are the ones who contributed
the most. They all got tired and went to the private groups on Yahoo or
CloudyNights. This was a much better place in the mid to late 90's.
Oriel is right. The Pledge is just a group hug, a big circle jerk.

Coppy Littlehouse wrote:
I don't know what planet you came from, but this group has
more trolls
on it today than ever before. Check out oriel's response on this
thread. It has never been as bad. And the local yocals still respond to
the trolls, over and over again. Did you see Davoud's troll bait on
Windows vs. Mac? The people who have left are the ones who contributed
the most. They all got tired and went to the private groups on Yahoo or
CloudyNights. This was a much better place in the mid to late 90's.
Oriel is right. The Pledge is just a group hug, a big circle jerk.

So if everyone ignored oriel, Davoud and the rest when they
troll?

We lost a lot of good contributors. But if we reduce the s/n
ratio we may not lose any more. We might even get some back.
But if we keep up long responses to trolls...

Clear Skies

Chuck Taylor
Do you observe the moon? If so, try
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/lunar-observing/

If you enjoy optics, try
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ATM_Optics_Software/
*********************************************