A Space & astronomy forum. SpaceBanter.com

Go Back   Home » SpaceBanter.com forum » Astronomy and Astrophysics » Astronomy Misc
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

SLIMEBALLS Still Directing Scientific "Truth" -- Velikovsky Affair



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
  #1  
Old June 30th 05, 10:39 PM
Ed Conrad
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default SLIMEBALLS Still Directing Scientific "Truth" -- Velikovsky Affair



"THE VELIKOVSKY AFFAIR"
Foreward
(by Alfred de Grazia)


In 1950, a book called Worlds in Collision, by Dr. Immanuel
Velikovsky, gave rise to a controversy in scientific and intellectual
circles about scientific theories and the sociology of science.

Dr. Velikovsky's historical and cosmological concepts, bolstered by
his
acknowledged scholarship, constituted a formidable assault on certain
established theories of astronomy, geology and historical biology, and
on the heroes of those sciences.

Newton, himself, and Darwin were being challenged, and indeed
the general orthodoxy of an ordered universe.

The substance of Velikovsky's ideas is briefly presented in the first
chapter of this book.

"What must be called the scientific establishment rose in arms, not
only against th new Velikovsky theories but against the man himself,"
wrote de Grazia.

"Efforts were made to block dissemination of Dr. Velikovsky's ideas,
and even to punish supporters of his investigations.

"Universities, scientific societies, publishing houses, the popular press =

were approached and threatened; social pressures and professional
sanctions=
were invoked to control public opinion.

"There is no doubt that in a totalitarian society, not only would Dr.
Velikovsky's reputation have been at stake, but also his right to
pursue his inquiry, and perhaps his own personal safety.

"As it was, the "establishment" succeeded in building a wall of
unfavorable sentiment around him: to thousands of scholars the name of
Velikovsky bears the taint of fantasy, science-fiction and publicity.

"He could not be suppressed entirely. In the next few years he
published three more books. He carried on a large correspondence. And
he was helped by friends and by a large general public composed of
persons outside of the establishments
of science.

"The probings of spacecraft tended to confirm -- never to disprove --
his arguments.

"Eventually, the venomous aspects of the controversy,
the efforts at suppression, the campaign of vilification
loomed almost as large, in their consequences to science,
as the original issue.


"Social scientists, who had been generally aware of Dr. Velikovsky's
work, now found themselves in the thick of the conflict.

"The involvement of the social and behavioral sciences in the
scientific theories of Velikovsky was higher than had been earlier
appreciated.

"The social sciences are the basis of Velikovsky's work: despite his
proficiency in the natural sciences, it is by the use of the
methodology of social science that Velikovsky launched his challenge
to
accepted cosmological theories.

"No one pretends that this method is adequate. New forms of
interdisciplinary research are needed to wed, for example, the study
of
myth with the study of meteorities.

"Nor does one have to agree that Velikovsky is the greatest technician
of mythology, even while granting his great conceptual and
synthesizing
powers.

"Whatever the scientific substance, the controversy inself could not
be
avoided or dismissed by behavioral science.

"The problem of science is one of the agitating problems of the 20th cent=

ury. The issues are clear:

WHO DETERMINES SCIENTIFIC TRUTH? (My caps, not his!)


WHO ARE ITS HIGH PRIESTS, AND WHAT IS THEIR
WARRANT?


HOW DO THEY ESTABLISH THEIR CANONS?


WHAT EFFECTS DO THEY HAVE ON THE FREEDOM
OF INQUIRY, AND ON PUBLIC INTEREST?


"In the end, some judgment M-U-S-T must be passed upon the behavior of
the scientific world and, if adverse, some remedies must be proposed .
.. .

"It is our hope that the publication of these papers in the present
volume (a revised and enlarged version) will make it less easy for
Velikovsky's new work to be suppressed, or lightly dismissed.

"We hope, too, that they will help scientists and interested laymen
everywhere to rehearse the problems and to REFORM THE ERRORS of the
vast enterprise of science."

=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=AD=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D

But a half-century late, things sure haven't changed. The disgraceful
Scientific Community is still belittling honest investigators,
berating
legitimate scientific evidence and badmouthing and blackballing
seekers
of The Truth.)

General Accounting Office (GAO), WHERE ARE YOU?

Isn't it time YOU lived up to your responsibility to protect
the American taxpayers' dollar and put your giant foot down on
the scoundrels who -- via their deceit, deception, collusion and
conspiracy, THEIR TOTAL DISHONESTY -- are keeping
the fresh air of truth from replacing the $tink of Science?

=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=AD=3D

Ed Conrad

http://www.edconrad.com


Man as Old as Coal
AND
Proof of Life After Death

=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=AD

http://www.edconrad.com/oldasc=ADoal.../quotesnew.gif

and
http://edconrad.com/canals/hoo=ADton.gif


=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=AD=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D

PETRIFIED BONES, TEETH AND SOFT ORGANS
DISCOVERED BETWEEN ANTHRACITE VEINS


Petrified human finger (with finger nail)
AND petrified human toe (with toe nail):

http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/A=ADu29/MVC-016S.JPG


http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/S=ADmith/z11calv.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/z8femur.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/z5gall.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/newtibia.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/skullb.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/z9lung.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/b=ADrain/MVC-001S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/N=ADewpix5/MVC-002S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/B=ADones/MVC-006S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/1tooth.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/N=ADewpix3/z3dino.jpg
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/MVC-013F.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/P=ADetrified/MVC-012F.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/D=ADay/MVC-005S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/S=ADcorpion/MVC-001S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/S=ADcorpion/MVC-010S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/S=ADcorpion/MVC-020S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/S=ADCORPIONS/MVC-039S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/T=ADool/MVC-003S.JPG
http://www.edconrad.com/ebay/T=ADool/MVC-005S.JPG


Ed Conrad

http://www.edconrad.com


Man as Old as Coal

=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=AD=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3 D=3D=3D=3D

Pennsylvania Senators:

Armstrong , Gibson E. (R) - District 13
Boscola , Lisa M. (D) - District 18
Brightbill , David J. (R) - District 48
Browne , Patrick M. (R) - District 16
Conti , Joe (R) - District 10
Corman , Jake (R) - District 34
Costa Jr. , Jay (D) - District 43
Earll , Jane M. (R) - District 49
Erickson , Edwin B. (R) - District 26
Ferlo , Jim (D) - District 38
Fontana , Wayne D. (D) - District 42
Fumo , Vincent J. (D) - District 1
Gordner , John R. (R) - District 27
Greenleaf , Stewart J. (R) - District 12
Hughes , Vincent J. (D) - District 7
Jubelirer , Robert C. (R) - District 30
Kasunic , Richard A. (D) - District 32
Kitchen , Shirley M. (D) - District 3
LaValle , Gerald J. (D) - District 47
Lemmond , Charles D. (R) - District 20
Logan , Sean (D) - District 45
Madigan , Roger A. (R) - District 23
Mellow , Robert J. (D) - District 22
Musto , Raphael J. (D) - District 14
O'Pake , Michael A. (D) - District 11
Orie , Jane Clare (R) - District 40
Piccola , Jeffrey E. (R) - District 15
Pileggi , Dominic F. (R) - District 9
Pippy , John R. (R) - District 37
Punt , Terry L. (R) - District 33
Rafferty, Jr. , John C. (R) - District 44
Regola , Bob (R) - District 39
Rhoades , James J. (R) - District 29
Robbins , Robert D. (R) - District 50
Scarnati , Joseph B. (R) - District 25
Stack , Michael J. (D) - District 5
Stout , J. Barry (D) - District 46
Tartaglione , Christine M. (D) - District 2
Thompson , Robert J. (R) - District 19
Tomlinson , Robert M. (R) - District 6
Vance , Patricia H (R) - District 31
Washington , LeAnna M. (D) - District 4
Waugh , Michael L. (R) - District 28
Wenger , Noah W. (R) - District 36
White , Donald C. (R) - District 41
White , Mary Jo (R) - District 21
Williams , Anthony H. (D) - District 8
Williams , Constance H. (D) - District 17
Wonderling , Robert C. (R) - District 24
Wozniak , John N. (D) - District 35
Pa. Members of House of Representatives

Adolph, Jr., William F. (R) - District 165
Allen, Bob (R) - District 125
Argall, David G. (R) - District 124
Armstrong, Gibson C. (R) - District 100
Baker, Matthew E. (R) - District 68
Baldwin, Roy E. (R) - District 97
Barrar, Stephen E. (R) - District 160
Bastian, Bob (R) - District 69
Bebko-Jones, Linda (D) - District 1
Belardi, Fred (D) - District 112
Belfanti, Jr., Robert E. (D) - District 107
Benninghoff, Kerry A. (R) - District 171
Biancucci, Vincent A. (D) - District 15
Birmelin, Jerry (R) - District 139
Bishop, Louise Williams (D) - District 192
Blackwell, IV, Thomas W. (D) - District 190
Blaum, Kevin (D) - District 121
Boyd, Scott W. (R) - District 43
Bunt, Jr., Raymond (R) - District 147
Butkovitz, Alan L. (D) - District 174
Buxton, Ronald I. (D) - District 103
Caltagirone, Thomas R. (D) - District 127
Cappelli, Steven W. (R) - District 83
Casorio, Jr., James E. (D) - District 56
Causer, Martin T. (R) - District 67
Cawley, Gaynor (D) - District 113
Civera, Jr., Mario J. (R) - District 164
Clymer, Paul I. (R) - District 145
Cohen, Mark B. (D) - District 202
Cornell, Susan E. (R) - District 152
Corrigan, Sr., Thomas C. (D) - District 140
Costa, Paul (D) - District 34
Crahalla, Jacqueline R. (R) - District 150
Creighton, Thomas C. (R) - District 37
Cruz, Angel (D) - District 180
Curry, Lawrence H. (D) - District 154
Daley, II, Peter J. (D) - District 49
Dally, Craig A. (R) - District 138
DeLuca, Anthony M. (D) - District 32
Denlinger, Gordon (R) - District 99
Dermody, Frank (D) - District 33
DeWeese, H. William (D) - District 50
DiGirolamo, Gene (R) - District 18
Diven, Michael (R) - District 22
Donatucci, Robert C. (D) - District 185
Eachus, Todd A. (D) - District 116
Ellis, Brian L. (R) - District 11
Evans, John R. (R) - District 5
Evans, Dwight (D) - District 203
Fabrizio, Florindo J. (D) - District 2
Fairchild, Russell H. (R) - District 85
Feese, Brett (R) - District 84
Fichter, John W. (R) - District 70
Fleagle, Patrick Elvin (R) - District 90
Flick, Robert J. (R) - District 167
Forcier, Teresa (R) - District 6
Frankel, Dan B. (D) - District 23
Freeman, Robert L. (D) - District 136
Gabig, William I. (R) - District 199
Gannon, Thomas P. (R) - District 161
Geist, Richard Allen (R) - District 79
George, Camille (D) - District 74
Gerber, Michael (D) - District 148
Gergely, Marc J. (D) - District 35
Gillespie, Keith J. (R) - District 47
Gingrich, Mauree A. (R) - District 101
Godshall, Robert W. (R) - District 53
Good, Matthew (R) - District 3
Goodman, Neal P. (D) - District 123
Grell, Glen R. (R) - District 87
Grucela, Richard T. (D) - District 137
Gruitza, Michael C. (D) - District 7
Habay, Jeffrey Earl (R) - District 30
Haluska, Gary (D) - District 73
Hanna, Michael K. (D) - District 76
Harhai, R. Ted (D) - District 58
Harhart, Julie (R) - District 183
Harper, Kate (R) - District 61
Harris, Adam (R) - District 82
Hasay, George
Hennessey, Tim (R) - District 26
Herman, Lynn B. (R) - District 77
Hershey, Arthur D. (R) - District 13
Hess, Dick Lee (R) - District 78
Hickernell, David S. (R) - District 98
Hutchinson, Scott E. (R) - District 64
James, Harold (D) - District 186
Josephs, Babette (D) - District 182
Kauffman, Rob (R) - District 89
Keller, Mark K. (R) - District 86
Keller, William F. (D) - District 184
Kenney, Jr., George T. (R) - District 170
Killion, Tom H. (R) - District 168
Kirkland, Thaddeus (D) - District 159
Kotik, Nick (D) - District 45
LaGrotta, Frank (D) - District 10
Leach, Daylin (D) - District 149
Lederer, Marie A. (D) - District 175
Leh, Dennis E. (R) - District 130
Lescovitz, Victor John (D) - District 46
Levdansky, David K. (D) - District 39
Mackereth, Beverly (R) - District 196
Maher, John A. (R) - District 40
Maitland, Stephen R. (R) - District 91
Major, Sandra J. (R) - District 111
Manderino, Kathy M. (D) - District 194
Mann, Jennifer L. (D) - District 132
Markosek, Joseph F. (D) - District 25
Marsico, Ronald S. (R) - District 105
McCall, Keith R. (D) - District 122
McGeehan, Michael P. (D) - District 173
McGill, Eugene F. (R) - District 151
McIlhattan, Fred (R) - District 63
McIlhinney, Jr., Charles T. (R) - District 143
McNaughton, Mark S. (R) - District 104
Melio, Anthony J. (D) - District 141
Metcalfe, Daryl D. (R) - District 12
Micozzie, Nicholas A. (R) - District 163
Millard, David (R) - District 109
Miller, Ronald E. (R) - District 93
Miller, Sheila (R) - District 129
Mundy, Phyllis (D) - District 120
Mustio, T. Mark (R) - District 44
Myers, John (D) - District 201
Nailor, Jerry L. (R) - District 88
Nickol, Steven R. (R) - District 193
O'Brien, Dennis M. (R) - District 169
O'Neill, Bernard T. (R) - District 29
Oliver, Frank L. (D) - District 195
Pallone, John E. (D) - District 54
Payne, John D. (R) - District 106
Perzel, John Michael (R) - District 172
Petrarca, Joseph A. (D) - District 55
Petri, Scott A. (R) - District 178
Petrone, Thomas C. (D) - District 27
Phillips, Merle H. (R) - District 108
Pickett, Tina (R) - District 110
Pistella, Frank J. (D) - District 21
Preston, Jr. , Joseph (D) - District 24
Pyle, Jeffrey P. (R) - District 60
Quigley, Thomas J. (R) - District 146
Ramaley, Sean M. (D) - District 16
Rapp, Kathy L. (R) - District 65
Raymond, Ron (R) - District 162
Readshaw, Harry A. (D) - District 36
Reed, Dave (R) - District 62
Reichley, Douglas G. (R) - District 134
Rieger, William W. (D) - District 179
Roberts, Lawrence (D) - District 51
Roebuck, Jr., James R. (D) - District 188
Rohrer, Samuel E. (R) - District 128
Rooney, T.J. (D) - District 133
Ross, Chris (R) - District 158
Rubley, Carole A. (R) - District 157
Ruffing, Kenneth W. (D) - District 38
Sainato, Chris (D) - District 9
Samuelson, Steve (D) - District 135
Santoni, Jr., Dante (D) - District 126
Sather, Larry O. (R) - District 81
Saylor, Stanley E. (R) - District 94
Scavello, Mario M. (R) - District 176
Schroder, Curt (R) - District 155
Semmel, Paul W. (R) - District 187
Shaner, James E. (D) - District 52
Shapiro, Josh (D) - District 153
Siptroth, John (D) - District 189
Smith, Samuel H. (R) - District 66
Smith, Bruce (R) - District 92
Solobay, Timothy J. (D) - District 48
Sonney, Curtis G. (R) - District 4
Staback, Edward G. (D) - District 115
Stairs, Jess M. (R) - District 59
Steil, David J. (R) - District 31
Stern, Jerry A. (R) - District 80
Stetler, Stephen H. (D) - District 95
Stevenson, Richard R. (R) - District 8
Stevenson, Thomas L. (R) - District 42
Sturla, P. Michael (D) - District 96
Surra, Dan A. (D) - District 75
Tangretti, Thomas A. (D) - District 57
Taylor, Elinor Z. (R) - District 156
Taylor, John J. (R) - District 177
Thomas, W. Curtis (D) - District 181
Tigue, Thomas M. (D) - District 118
True, Katie (R) - District 41
Turzai, Mike (R) - District 28
Veon, Michael R. (D) - District 14
Vitali, Greg S. (D) - District 166
Walko, Don (D) - District 20
Wansacz, Jim (D) - District 114
Waters, Ronald G. (D) - District 191
Watson, Katharine M. (R) - District 144
Wheatley, Jr., Jake (D) - District 19
Williams, Jewell (D) - District 197
Wilt, Rod E. (R) - District 17
Wojnaroski, Sr., Edward P. (D) - District 71
Wright, Matthew N. (R) - District 142
Yewcic, Thomas F. (D) - District 72
Youngblood, Rosita C. (D) - District 198
Yudichak, John T. (D) - District 119
Pennsylvania Newspaper Association [Harrisburg]


Allentown Times [Allentown]
Beaver County Times [Beaver]
The Bradford Era [Bradford]
Bridgeville Star [Bridgeville]
Bucks County Courier Times [Levittown]
Butler Eagle [Butler]
Centre Daily Times [State College]
Chester County Press [Oxford]
Citizen Standard [Valley View]
The Citizens Voice [Wilkes Barre]
City Paper [Philadelphia]
Clarion News [Clarion]
Coraopolis Record [Coropolis]
The Courier-Express [Du Bois]
Cranberry Journal [Cranberry]
The Daily American [Somerset]
Daily Courier [Connellsville]
The Daily Item [Sunbury]
Daily Local News [West Chester]
Daily News [McKeesport]
Daily Review [Towanda]
The Danville News [Danville]
Delaware County Daily Times [Primos]
The Derrick [Oil City]
Ellwood City Ledger [Ellwood City]
Erie Daily Times/Morning News [Erie]
The Evening Sun [Hanover]
The Evening Times [Sayre]
The Express [Lock Haven]
The Express-Times [Easton]
Forest City News [Forest City]
The Fulton County News [McConnellsburg]
The Gettysburg Times [Gettysburg]
Greene County Messenger [Waynesburg]
The Herald [Sharon]
Herald-Standard [Uniontown]
The Indiana Gazette [Indiana]
Intelligencer/The Record [Doylestown]
Leader Times [Kittanning]
The Main Line Times [Ardmore]
The Mercury [Pottstown]
Moon Record [Moon Township]
The Morning Call [Allentown]
Mountaintop Eagle [Mountaintop]
Murrysville Star [Murrysville]
New Castle News [New Castle]
News-Item [Shamokin]
North Hills News Record [Warrendale]
North Journal [Wexford]
Northeast News Gleaner [Philadelphia]
Norwin Star [Irwin]
Oakmont Advance Leader [Oakmont]
Observer-Reporter [Washington]
Patriot News [Harrisburg]
Penn Hills Progress [Penn Hills]
Perry County Times [New Bloomfield]
Philadelphia Business Journal [Philadelphia]
Philadelphia Inquirer [Philadelphia]
Philadelphia Daily News [Philadelphia]
Philadelphia Weekly [Philadelphia]
Pittsburgh Business Times [Pittsburgh]
Pittsburgh City Paper [Pittsburgh]
The Phoenix [Phoenixville]
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette [Pittsburgh]
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review [Pittsburgh]
Plum Advance Leader [Plum]
Pocono Record [Stroudsburg]
Pottsville Republican [Pottsville]
Press-Enterprise [Bloomsburg]
The Progress News [Emlenton]
Reading Times/Reading Eagle [Reading]
The Record Herald [Waynesboro]
Rocket-Courier [Wyalusing]
Scranton Times/The Tribune [Scranton]
The Sentinel [Carlisle]
The Sentinel [Lewistown]
Sewickly Herald [Sewickly]
Signal Item - Star [Carnegie]
South Hills Record [Monroeville]
Standard Observer [Irwin]
Standard-Speaker [Hazleton]
Times Express [Monroeville]
The Times Herald [Norristown]
The Times Leader [Wilkes-Barre]
The Times News [Lehighton]
Titusville Herald [Titusville]
The Tribune-Democrat [Johnstown]
Tribune-Review [Greensburg]
Upper Dauphin Sentinel [Millersburg]
The Valley Herald [Aspinwall]
Valley Independent [Monessen]
Valley News Dispatch [Tarentum]
Voices of Central PA [State College]
The Wayne Independent [Honesdale]
Wayne Suburban [Wayne]
The Weekender [Wilkes-Barre]
The Weekly Journal [Moscow]
Williamsport Sun-Gazette [Williamsport]
Woodland Progress [Forest Hills]
York Daily Record [York]=20
York Dispatch [York]

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
HAPPY HOLIDAY - Only 197 Shopping Days 'Til Christmas... Smallest Woman - Skeleton - Intelligent Design - Extraterrestrial ? Berlin Exhibit Ed Conrad Astronomy Misc 0 May 30th 05 01:20 PM
Ho! Ho! HUMBUG! Ed Conrad Astronomy Misc 0 November 14th 04 01:34 PM
Scientific Reception or Is It Deception? Ed Conrad Astronomy Misc 3 November 1st 04 09:32 PM
How to Remove the S (Stink) from Science Ed Conrad Astronomy Misc 0 November 1st 04 01:42 PM
Let's Destroy The Myth Of Astrology!! GFHWalker Astronomy Misc 11 December 9th 03 10:28 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:55 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 SpaceBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.