(Sergey Karavashkin) wrote in message . com...
TO ALL COLLEAGUES:

Dear Colleagues,

I always wonder, how do you confuse yourself by substituting the
statement of problem by the desirable model. What concern
RC-oscillator has here? The wave model of photoeffect is based on
interaction of EM wave with orbital electrons of atom. Resonance
characteristics of electrons movement in their orbit define the
stationary processes in atom. You would re-read Niels Bohr. Secondary
wave excited by electrons is possible only in transitions between the
resonance states. The same, transitions of orbital electrons between
the levels are possible only in case if both levels are stable.
Transitions from the stable level to some unstable location lead to
the spontaneous emission of electron and to returning to the stable
level. Or rather, factually the processes will be more complicated
there, but in your trivial plane terminology it sounds approximately
so. Again, read Bohr. And please don't model any waveguides either
oscillators in order to substitute EM wave as an external affection
onto the resonance system by some model propagating the wave within a
waveguide either cable. These models don't correlate!

Again, as to resonance. If resonance is not the characteristic of
vibration system, what are we speaking about, at all? Resonance has
been introduced as a concept inalienable from the dynamics of
vibration system. Now you are revising and take it away from the wave
physics? Well done, Colleagues!


" Resonance has been introduced as a concept inalienable
from the dynamics of vibration system."

Excepting me, all participants of a controversy avoid arguing
properties of a PARAMETRIC RESONANCE. They reduce all kinds
of a resonance in an electricity only to a Helmholtz resonance,
i.e. to the theory of a resonance of the nineteenth century.
(XIX century!!!).

This problem is interlinked to psychology of thinking
by physical stereotypes.
The overcoming of error physical stereotypes of thinking
is the PURPOSE of the given controversy.

REVERSIBLE MODEL of a PARAMETRIC RESONANCE
during absorption and radiation
of electromagnetic radiation by Atom.

THE REQUIREMENTS to MODEL.

0. The atom is active dynamic system, i.e. atom and its
elements are not passive systems.
1. Reversibility of the mechanism.
2. Usage of the mechanism of a complex parametric resonance.
3. Explanation of existence of the Planck constant from
positions of the mechanism of a complex parametric
resonance.


REVERSIBLE MODEL of absorption and radiation by Atom
OR
REVERSIBLE MODEL of processes of ABSORPTION and RADIATION
of electromagnetic radiation by Atom.



The atom absorbs and radiates electromagnetic radiation,
which one has a wave length superior the size of atom many
times over, i.e.:

(lambda E/M radiation) (d = size of atom)

^
wave direction |
|
|
|
|