View Single Post
  #6  
Old April 10th 13, 03:31 AM posted to sci.astro
dlzc
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,426
Default A Big Bang conundrum

Dear JAAKKO KURHI:

On Tuesday, April 9, 2013 5:48:35 PM UTC-7, JAAKKO KURHI wrote:
....
The observer cannot see a 13 billion years-old light
unless the observer is located 13 billion light-years
away from the point the light was emitted. How this
event works with the Big-Bang model, where the
emitted light and the observer originated from the
same young and small universe.


The CMBR light was emitted from a nearly fully -ized Universe. Inflation lets you outrun the light. Besides, the light could go round and round a closed Universe.

Theoretically, it can work if the Milky-Way as an
observer and the emitted light rays traveled near
same speed and near parallel paths, until 13
billion years later the Milky-Way is observing
these old lights.


"Only" way? No, clearly you operate from complete ignorance. You choose to spout, rather than learn.

This event is not happening. The Milky-Way travels
only 300 km/sec. In the environment of the Big-Bang
model, this speed is not enough to reach the
position for observing 13 billion years old light
rays.


"Conundrum", no.

Therefore, those observed 13 billion years-old
lights are not coming from the small, young and
compact universe.


So sad you spend time justifying, rather than learning.

David A. Smith