On 28 Mar, 08:10, HW@....(Henri Wilson) wrote:
On Sun, 25 Mar 2007 23:34:03 +0100, "George Dishman" wrote:
"Henri Wilson" HW@.... wrote in message

George, when you can, have a look at

http://www.users.bigpond.com/hewn/ellip_circle.jpg

This shows how an elliptical orbit can produce a near perfect sine wave under
certain condition whilst the circular orbit produces nothing like one for
exactly the same parameter values.

Yaw angle is -90 (periastron closest to observer).

The white curve is an exact sinewave.

You might like to consider how the elliptical orbit's
curve will change with distance. For example can you
do the same at a distance where VDoppler and ADoppler
are of equat magnitude (the 45 degree case for a
circular orbit).


In recent measages you seem to have been switching
between saying VDoppler doesn't exist at all and saying
it exists but is negligible presumably because it is
much smaller than ADoppler. I have held off replying to
see if you would clarify that (and also I was out last
night and we had visitors at the weekend). I've also
been tinkering with a GUI and might do a simulation for
comparison with yours but I have a couple of other
projects I'm working on too so I may not spend too much
time duplicating what you've already done. Does your
program actually include VDoppler or not?

George