In article ,
"Alfred A. Aburto Jr." wrote:
Mitchell Jones wrote:
***{Does anyone have an explanation for the following? --MJ}***
Forwarding permission was given by William R. Corliss
http://www.science-frontiers.com
SCIENCE FRONTIERS, No. 159, May-Jun 2005, p. 4
GEOPHYSICS
Extreme LDEs
LDEs (Long-Delayed Echoes) are heard fairly often by radio hams. Usually,
their signals are reflected back to them delayed by just a few seconds. But
since radio waves travel 186,000 miles/second, any reflector must be located
far beyond the moon's orbit. Question: what's out there?
LDEs have been recognized and puzzled over since 1927. (SF#10, SF#39)
But so far no completely convincing explanation has been forthcoming. Three
ideas thrown on the table have been:
* Multiple trips of the signal around the world with the ionosphere's help.
* Signal trapping in ionospheric ducts.
* Reflections from distant plasma clouds.
Most LDE research has been carried out by radio hams, who have now
discovered a new twist to the LDE puzzle: some LDEs return not in
just a few seconds but in minutes and even hours! Can you imagine
a radio reflector a light-hour distant? After all, the sun is only 8
light-minutes away.
Japanese hams have been at the forefront in collecting these extremely long
LDEs. M. Obara, in Tokyo (call letters TZ6JA), summarized the situation
as follows.
All of these records (except UL7GW) indicate very long delay
times ranging from 20 minutes to 82 hours. Converting these
times to distances...corresponds to round trips of 1.8 - 297 AU
(Astronomical Unit, 1 AU = 150 million kilometers, or about
93 million miles, the distance between the Earth and the Sun).
These delay times suggest the existence of two hypothetical
*interplanetary ionospheres*, composed of numerous magnetic
and plasma tails of small planets and debris, located mainly at
the minor planet belt (asteroid belt) and the Kuiper belt (a
region beyond Neptune containing thousands of small bodies
orbiting the sun that is believed to be the spawning ground
of many short-period comets.
(Obara, Mac; "Long-Delayed Echoes: Reflections from an Ionosphere in
Space?", *CQ*, 24, Feb 2005. Cr. L.M. Nash)
SCIENCE FRONTIERS is a bimonthly collection of scientific anomalies in
the current literature. Published by the Sourcebook Project, P.O. Box 107,
Glen Arm, MD 21057 USA. Annual subscription: $8.00.
What is the source of the echo?
***{Frankly, it seems so bizarre to me that I can come up with only one
theory: hams are playing tricks on one another. One ham sends out a
signal, and another records it and plays it back later. In other words,
it's sort of like an internet hoax. Could that be? I don't know, but if
it isn't then this is one of the strangest things I've ever heard of.
--MJ}***
I don't think they are reflections from the Kuiper Belt Objects.
***{I totally agree. --MJ}***
Their
(Kuiper Belt Objects) spatial density probably (I'm guessing this) is
not sufficient to have much of a reflection coefficient. Also the 2-way
propagation loss (Earth to Kuiper Belt, reflection loss, and then the
return path: Kuiper Belt to Earth) would be very large (that is I doubt
it would be detectable under normal transmission conditions).
***{Again, I agree. Either it is a hoax, or some very strange physics is
involved. --MJ}***
Are there examples of this signal on the web?
***{I don't know. I subscribe to a list where the above material
appeared as a post, and it seemed so strange to me that I just passed it
on, in hopes that someone here could shed some light on it. --MJ}***