[insert any contemporary stargazer] is likely the most gifted observer of
our generation (if not ever).

these days reaching 'exceptional observer' status can be
reached
by merely claiming to see faint or otherwise difficult objects.

Nonsense. Observing skills are as important today as they ever were...And
there is no doubt whatsoever that some people have better skills (and better
eyes) than others...

pull your head out of your ass, cloudbait. nobody said observing skills weren't
important or that everyone's eyesight or skill level was the same.
i was addressing the audacious claims made by many in this hobby, made only to
exaggerate their prowess. we all know it happens.
of course there are amateurs who have more experience and skill than others.
it's the accomplishments they've made from their skills
that make them exceptional observers, regardless of whether they can see to the
8th magnitude or not.
the early major accomplishments made with little or no technological
aid are much more impressive to me.