Doesn't your hypothesis presume we both started in exactly the same spot and
only one of us moved. If you put 2 dots on a rubber band and stretch it,
neither dot will actually be moving (relative to the rubber band), but they
will move away from each other.

"Dark Helmet" wrote in message
...

So, the question remains, how did the nebula get 12 billion light years
away
from us when the universe was only 2 billion years old? Particularly when
the speed of light is supposed to be the max speed of anything?