On Thu, 03 Jan 13, Phillip Helbig wrote:
I don't think you've made a very convincing case here.

Absolutely right. I haven't laid out anything comprehensive because
it's not ready and I did say a couple times that my goal was to
present it in the early 2013 if I could sort out the issues. These
discussion have helped to sort out individual issues.

If you believe publication bias is so rampant, then think of all
the stuff you don't know about. :-)

Right again, and that applies to us all.

Also, make sure that YOU don't have a bias here, i.e.
that you aren't giving too much weight to one paper and too little to
several others.

Exactly, for me to state that the dependency of CMB temperature with
redshift is ill-founded, I need to read the whole literature on that
topic. A big ask for an amateur like me, with limited time available.
Which is why I can't be more definitive or convincing at this time, or
maybe any time soon. But thanks for the helpful discussions.

Eric